Can Damlaları

Minah [211-240]

Minah-211:

One day in the exalted assembly, the saying of some great ones, "no regard is given to the tariqa practices performed without the permission of the Master of the Time (sahib-i zaman)," was brought up: it was said that it had been put to Imam Rabbani (k.s), that he affirmed that no regard is given, but qualified this regard as meaning perfect regard, and the question was raised of what the state of one who does not know the Master of the Time, or who is far from him, would be. Ghawth (k.s) said: One who does not know the Master of the Time is excused just like one who is far away. For a murid who is in the station of annihilation (fana), his perfect regard for his own sheikh through obedience is sufficient, whether there is a Master of the Time or not.

Minah-212:

Suhba cuts the tie with all that is other than God. Khwaja Azizan (k.s) used to interpret his craft, weaving, as "separating and joining." Ghawth (k.s) used to interpret the saying of some great ones, "Come, let us be believers for an hour," taking the words "let us be believers" as the effect (faith) used in place of its cause (suhba), that is, he would explain it by suhba: what is meant by "let us believe" is "let us keep company in suhba."

Minah-213:

The angels come to the assembly of suhba. For this reason the sheikh is called "Pir-i Mughan." For in the interpretation of dreams and unveilings, the "mughan," that is, the unbelievers, mean angels. Ghawth (k.s) was asked what the purpose of the angels in attending the suhba of the sheikhs might be: if it were to secure the presence of the heart with God (Exalted is He), they are already in that state; if it were for advancement, they do not go beyond a fixed station. Ghawth (k.s) said: –"The angels attend in order to taste delight."

Minah-214:

Ghawth (k.s), relating from the states of some suhba sheikhs, said: "Those who perform loud dhikr are heedless of the meaning and the station of dhikr." By this saying, what Ghawth (k.s) meant were the dhakirs of our time who make dhikr a tool and perform it with very loud voices and noise. Ghawth (k.s), interpreting the word "station," said: "The proof for audible dhikr (dhikr-i jahr), as Azizan (k.s) also explained, is this well-known noble hadith: 'Whoever's last words are La ilaha illallah will enter Paradise.'
The murid should count each of his breaths as his last breath and act accordingly. The rationale of audible dhikr is that the one performing dhikr counts every breath as his last and remains in that state, (not that he says it with his mouth).

Minah-215:

Ghawth (k.s) said: "A person of greater excellence benefits from the suhba of one of lesser excellence. Suhba is never devoid of blessing. Sometimes what is not found with the more excellent is found with the less excellent. He mentioned the stories of Moses (peace be upon him), a prophet of firm resolve, and Khidr (peace be upon him), whose prophethood is disputed, and the companionship between Sheikh al-Islam Ahmad al-Jami and Abu Fakhir al-Kurdi (k.s).

Minah-216:

To point out that it is not permissible for one who is able to find proof to take a sheikh of the will (irada) by imitation, for the sheikh is in truth the murid's qibla, and that one capable of independent reasoning may not follow another blindly in the qibla, Ghawth (k.s) said: "The scholars are not like the common people in taking a sheikh. On the contrary, they must be cautious and seek a sheikh until it becomes clear to them through a proof." And they related this story: "Shah-i Naqshband (k.s) asked Mulla Yaqub-i Charkhi (k.s) why he had accepted him as a sheikh; he answered, because the people accepted you. The Shah (k.s) refuted this by saying that this proof could be a satanic one. Thereupon Yaqub-i Charkhi (k.s) answered with this well-known noble hadith: "When God (Exalted is He) loves a servant, He casts that love into the hearts of the angels. And when He is displeased with a servant, He casts that displeasure and aversion into the hearts of the angels. Then He places that love or displeasure in the hearts of people as well." [36] Then Shah-i Naqshband (k.s) asked for a clearer proof than this, and he reminded him of the dream in which he had been commanded "Become a murid of Azizan." He said that the Azizan meant in this dream was himself. There are many benefits in this story. Detailed information will be given in our book called Lem'a. (For this story, see Rashahat.) On this subject the story of the four scholars is famous; these scholars set out on a journey to search for a sheikh, and after a long journey they came upon Zenci Ata (k.s), whom they did not know, grazing camels. (This story is found in detail in Rashahat.) Three of these scholars recognized Zenci Ata (k.s) and followed him. But Sayyid Ata attached himself by imitation of his companions (because his companions had attached themselves to him). For a certain time he saw no benefit from him. Ghawth (k.s) said: "The essence of bringing proof is for the salik to compare his states before and after the suhba. If the aim in the suhba is gained, namely the gathering of the heart and the repelling or lessening of stray thoughts, then he is the sheikh he is seeking. If none of these occurs, let him leave him, otherwise the spirits of the sheikhs will not forgive him." This quatrain of Hazrat Azizan (k.s) is famous:

"With whomever you sat, your heart was not gathered,
The toil of your water and clay did not leave you,
If you do not turn away from his company,
Surely the spirit of Azizan will not forgive you."

Ghawth (k.s) used to interpret the word "azizan" in the last line not as Hazrat Azizan (k.s) but as "the Sheikhs."

Minah-217:

When Abu Bakr al-Wasiti (k.s) came to Nishapur, he asked the community of Abu Uthman al-Hiri (k.s):
-"What does your master command you?"
They answered:
"He commands us to see our own faults and to accuse our selves in every circumstance."
To this answer Abu Bakr al-Wasiti (k.s) said:
-"He commands you merely to Zoroastrianism, because this seeing is merely seeing two things that are opposed to tawhid." Upon these words in the exalted assembly, a faqir asked Ghawth (k.s):
-"Which is your inclination?" Ghawth (k.s) said:
-"Our way is to see the fault." The story of Hazrat Shah (k.s) in Nafahat is a good proof of this. Hazrat Shah said: Hold your own selves to blame. The saying of al-Wasiti leans toward the unity of being (wahdat al-wujud). It may also be taken as referring to times when the murid brings nothing to his heart.

Minah-218:

Ghawth (k.s) says in this suhba: "Between the servant and God there are twelve veils. Six of these veils are of light and six are of darkness. Union is not possible until all these veils are lifted and removed. To have these veils lifted, one must find a perfect sheikh. They are not lifted without the spiritual aid (himma) and training of a sheikh who has returned in perfection. A sheikh with a deficient relation (nisba) cannot lift these veils either; he only gilds them with other things, the murid thinks that the veils have been lifted, but in truth they have not."

Minah-219:

Sayyid Taha (k.s) strongly recommended to his murids the reading and study of the one hundred and twenty drops (rashha) related from Khwaja-i Ahrar (k.s) in the book Rashahat, and would say: "The Naqshbandi tariqa is what is in Rashahat." Ghawth (k.s) recommended the same work, following his sheikh.

Minah-220:

"Just as outward knowledge delays the salik, so does the knowledge of unveiling. It occupies the salik," said Ghawth (k.s); "without his sheikh's permission, the salik sometimes knows the difference between shadows and originals and sometimes does not." He said: "The person who does not discover the difference is closer to safety. All unveilings are a trial and a test. The salik who inclines to them stays with them and cannot advance. In the presence of my sheikh Sayyid Taha (k.s) there was a man of unveiling who asked me about certain matters. This person was not yet counted among the Naqshbandis.

Minah-221:

Ghawth (k.s) preferred the denier to the claimant (one who claims a station he does not possess) and would say: "The denier may well return, but the claimant cannot return." He said: "Claiming is a veil that prevents every benefit."

Minah-222:

With the gnostic ('arif), the attributes of the self are not uprooted entirely; some elements remain, but these can no longer stand against the gnostic. The attributes of the self weaken and collapse until no trace of them can be seen. If some persons who are under the captivity and bondage of those attributes keep company with the gnostic, some of their states are reflected onto him. The gnostic imagines these attributes to be his own; however, the reflected attribute has no power to stand against the gnostic.

Minah-223:

Ghawth (k.s) said: "Only the company of bad companions is of benefit." Right after these words he would interpret the phrase "bad companion" as one who beholds his own self as evil and sees it as utterly flawed, and he would say: "Since there is no greater sin than seeing the self as faultless, only their company is of benefit."

Minah-224:

Ghawth (k.s) was asked: "Is it possible to hold constant presence (huzur) together with seeing the self as flawed and calling the self to account?" He answered: "Yes, it is possible together; once presence has been gained, nothing can prevent it."

Minah-225:

The saying of Imam Rabbani (k.s), "The one drowned in God (mustaghraq) loves God (Exalted is He) more than the Prophet (peace be upon him). The one who has returned loves the Prophet (peace be upon him) more than the love of God (Exalted is He)," was put to Ghawth (k.s), and he answered: "Yes, his saying is so. The overwhelming of the love of God (Exalted is He) keeps the one who has returned from the exercise of authority he is charged with, whereas the love of the Prophet (peace be upon him) does not keep him from it.

[34 In the books of etiquette (adab) we have, it is stated that rabita is performed before dhikr and after dhikr. But there is no engagement with rabita at the time of the wird. That Ghawth (k.s) said "combine them if possible," pointing out that doing both together is not for everyone but only for one who has the strength to do both together, may be a special temperament of Ghawth (k.s). And God knows best.]
[35 Fayd al-Qadir p. 206, No: 8961]
[36 Ramuz al-Ahadith 295]

Minah-226:

Is there benefit in being together with the perfect ones and going about with them without any relation of being a murid to any of them? Ghawth (k.s) was asked. He answered:
"Not much benefit."

Minah-227:

When the seeker (talib) finds a person qualified for guidance, he should delay surrendering to him as a murid. However, if the seeker wants a tariqa other than the path of that perfect one, and the tariqa he wants appeals to him in such a way that it forbids benefiting from other tariqas, the seeker need not surrender and may give up. After these words Ghawth (k.s) related this story: "Before Khwaja Ahrar (k.s) met Yaqub-i Charkhi (k.s), he had the opportunity to become a murid of several perfect ones such as Sayyid Qasim-i Tabrizi, Baha al-Din-i Umar and Zayn al-Din-i Khwafi (k.s), but he postponed his discipleship, because he had liked the Naqshbandi tariqa as a path and chosen it."

Minah-228:

"The heat of longing dies out completely in union. Love is not so. While far from his sheikh, the murid knows his love better," he would say, and with this indication he used to console one who was grieved in his presence by the deficiency of his love. Ghawth (k.s) added to these words:
"One of the great ones of the people of love died burning with the heat of love, but he was not among those who had attained union." Interpreting this non-attainment of union by the variety of the degrees of union, Ghawth (k.s) said: "The one who died has attained union; only, the degree of union has no end." Ghawth (k.s) asked a faqir about this saying that belongs to one of the great ones:
"If You wish, unite me; if You wish, do not unite me." Although the one who said this was among those who had arrived, what is the purpose of this wavering (terdid)? The faqir answered: "It is a choice between the union one is in and a higher union." Ghawth (k.s) said: "Yes, that is so."

Minah-229:

Imam Rabbani (k.s) forbade his khalifas to give the tariqa without checking the sincerity of those who came to them and without performing istikhara together with them several times. Yet in this day it is not so. The tariqa is given to everyone who comes. This is because some khalifas who were permitted to give the tariqa introduced this as if it belonged to the origin of the tariqa, and those who came after them followed them. They asked: Is doing so not contrary to what Imam Rabbani (k.s) did? Ghawth (k.s) said: "The reason for the said prohibition and checking is to bring out the sincerity in the murid's essence, because turning back after accepting the sheikh and entering the tariqa is worse than not entering at the outset. Imam Rabbani (k.s) himself did not do so." I think the questioner understood "the prohibition and checking" as applying to one for whom the khilafa is necessary, and said: "Are the khalifas of necessity in this century also charged with istikhara and checking?" Ghawth (k.s) said: "No," and continued: "My sheikh at the outset commanded me to perform istikhara with the murid up to three times, then he lifted this command." I think that Ghawth (k.s) pointed out that the permission for guidance given at the outset, which enabled him to return to the source (marja')[37], covers all of his time and includes the individuals who turn to him. With this he has no need to ask permission anew. Perhaps he renews it for some wisdom. But the khalifas who took permission from the one who returned are not so. The one who has returned exercises authority (tasarruf) over their permission as he sees fit, restricting it (taqyid) or leaving it unrestricted (itlaq). It is the same even for the one who has returned from them and reached the station of completion. In truth, if the sheikh is alive, however high his khalifa may rise, it is forbidden for him to be independent in his command. He pointed out that only rarely may it be otherwise. Although this subject belonged to the Lem'a, the obscurity of the Minhah caused it to be hastened.

Minah-230:

Saying that mentioning sermons and tales in the assembly is not sheikhhood but rather contrary to it, Ghawth (k.s) said: "That the khalifas of the time adorn their assemblies with sermons and stories is because the inner power and relation (nisba), which is the capital of sheikhhood, are not in their hands. What they do has not been seen among the sheikhs of the silsila. The chief of the tariqa, Shah-i Naqshband (k.s), said: "Our tariqa is nothing but suhba."[38]

Minah-231:

Complete sincerity is to act in accordance with the sheikh's wish, whether or not the sheikh's word, deed and state contradict the clear rulings. He should affirm without even denial, or asking about the meaning of a matter, entering his heart. Ghawth (k.s) said:
"One day our sheikh Sayyid Taha (k.s) spoke to the scholars about the spirit. One of the scholars said, in the manner of denial:
-'The sheikh speaks about the spirit, while God Almighty (Exalted is He) says:
وَيَسْـَٔلُونَكَ عَنِ الرُّوحِۜ قُلِ الرُّوحُ مِنْ اَمْرِ رَبّ۪ي وَمَٓا اُو۫ت۪يتُمْ مِنَ الْعِلْمِ اِلَّا قَل۪يلًاThey ask you ˹O Prophet˺ about the spirit. Say, “Its nature is known only to my Lord, and you ˹O humanity˺ have been given but little knowledge.” (Al-Isra 17:85, Diyanet)[39]'. Upon this the sheikh said:
–'The spirit there is the animal spirit, while we are speaking of the human spirit.'
Ghawth (k.s) said about this situation: "When the sheikh left the assembly, a learned and sincere Sufi said to the one who had recited the noble verse: if you had not spoken, nothing would have come to my heart concerning the sheikh's words."
I think that Ghawth (k.s), out of respect for the verse and so that the questioner might understand, interposed a clarification of his sheikh's answer, and after this narration said: "Is the human spirit not also of the command?"

Minah-232:

I think that, pointing out that the most beautiful sincerity is surrender not by forcing oneself but with contentment and delight, Ghawth (k.s) said: "Two scholars among the followers of our sheikh were talking; one said to the other, what would you do if the sheikh commanded you not to pray? The other said: I would obey the command reluctantly. The scholar who asked the question said: I would obey willingly and with a glad heart.

Minah-233:

Ghawth (k.s), finding it strange that a sheikh who lived in his time, and in whose suhba he had been, taught his murids the rabita of his own sheikh who was no longer alive, said: "How can the rabita of one who is in the world of barzakh benefit one who is in the world of witnessing?" I held to the command of that sheikh and for a time continued the rabita of his sheikh, who was not alive, as the sheikh had commanded. It appeared to me only as "a distant image in a fog." It would not appear in any other form.

Minah-234:

Ghawth (k.s) used to say: The sheikh whose rabita brings benefit is the sheikh who is awake at all times.

Minah-235:

Ghawth (k.s) said to a faqir: "Do not suppose that your passing from state to state comes from the sheikh being heedless of your heart or neglecting you; it is only from the changeability (talwin) of the heart."

Minah-236:

The murid keeps suhba with the person he finds among the perfect ones of the time, only he must not be heedless of the rabita of his own sheikh during the suhba. The benefit he gains from the suhba he must also know to be only from his own rabita.

Ghawth (k.s), adding to these blessed words, said that the murid also keeps suhba with one who is more perfect than his own sheikh. Khalid al-Uleki (k.s) says that in these words he was silent on whether the rabita is a condition or not.
A faqir asked Ghawth (k.s): "You become the murid of one sheikh and attach yourself to him, and yet you believe that someone else is more perfect than your own sheikh; how can this be?"

Ghawth (k.s) said: "After a person becomes a murid, the Almighty Truth (Exalted is He) creates in him the perception that someone else is more perfect than his own sheikh."[40]

Minah-237:

I think that Ghawth (k.s) indicated that the suhba of a perfect and more perfect one other than one's sheikh benefits the murid only if his love has not gone wholly to his sheikh and some place remains in which he could incline to another; but if his love has gone to his sheikh and nothing of it remains, then suhba with another is not for benefit but only for acquaintance and blessing; and he would say: "Once, when going to visit my sheikh, I stopped at Van. When I arrived in Van, I learned that one of the khalifas of Mawlana Khalid al-Baghdadi (k.s), whom my sheikh himself described as perfect, had come there. I did not go to visit him. When I came to visit my sheikh, I told him the situation. He said to me: why did you not go to him?… I said, I go to no one but you. My sheikh said to me: you should have gone and come to know what he is like."

Minah-238:

I think that, to point out that remaining in a lower station and taking on its state is better than hurrying to rise to a higher station, Ghawth (k.s) said: in the world of images (alam al-mithal) I saw the state of two persons of this group; they were in the form of fruit-bearing trees. Of these I saw the one whose fruit was unripe as tall, and the one whose fruit was ripe as short. I submitted these states to my sheikh. My sheikh said: "The ripe short one is better than the unripe tall one."

Minah-239:

Ghawth (k.s) said: "The relation (nisba) of an unlettered (ummi) saint is purer than that of a learned saint. Although the learned saint is higher than the unlettered in station, the unlettered becomes purer than the learned, because the imprints of learning muddy the nisba."

Minah-240:

Ghawth (k.s), with the intention of pointing out to the murid that a person whose nisba is small but pure is more beneficial than a person whose nisba is great but muddy, would prefer one suhba sheikh over another suhba sheikh in terms of seeing benefit.

Back to the table of contents