Minah [271-307]

Minah-271:
I think, in order to point to the difficulty of recognizing the knower of God (arif), Ghawth (k.s.) said: "It was said to me (by way of inspiration): the person who carries you is the most perfect of his age."
Minah-272:
Ghawth (k.s.)'s son Molla Bahaüddin had gone to some regions to teach the tariqa. A few days later, news reached them that great crowds had gathered in the places he had gone to and that people were streaming to visit him. Ghawth (k.s.) said to a murid: "The people have turned to Bahaüddin!"; the murid, rejoicing, praised God (Exalted is He) and said: "We hope, through my master's himmat, that this good fortune will increase." Ghawth (k.s.) said: "But I am saddened by it."
Minah-273:
Ghawth (k.s.) said: "A group from the community of my shaykh Seyyid Taha (k.s.) were sitting in his mosque performing muraqaba. All of them had turned their faces to the qibla and their backs to the shaykh's house. One of them, turning his face to the house, said, 'Turn your faces to the tavern, to the place where the nisba is.' I found this saying beautiful.
Minah-274:
One of the sufis who served Ghawth (k.s.) related: "Ghawth (k.s.), I and some friends were visiting Seyyid Taha (k.s.). After we had stayed a few days, the friends longed for their homes; Seyyid Taha (k.s.) gave his friends leave but kept Ghawth (k.s.) waiting. I said to Seyyid Taha (k.s.): 'If only you would give leave to the khalifa too; he has no one to look after his house and do his work.' Seyyid Taha (k.s.) said: 'Do I, or the khalifa, have a house? May God Most High (Exalted is He) destroy first my house and then his.' Ghawth (k.s.) was there at that time. Afterwards, because of this conversation, I feared that he would scold me. When we rose from the exalted gathering, Ghawth (k.s.) took me by the sash and said: 'So-and-so! It is sometimes good that there is an ignorant person in exalted gatherings. By God (Exalted is He), until now there was in me a little attachment to the world. With Seyyid Taha (k.s.)'s saying 'May He destroy my house and your house,' this attachment has gone.'"
I (Halid-i Öleki) heard some matters in the Minah directly, but I have mentioned together what I heard from Ghawth (k.s.) and what I heard from the narrator.
Minah-275:
One of the murids related: "Ghawth (k.s.) addressed a sufi: 'So-and-so! Do the murids act as shepherds at dawn?' With these words Ghawth (k.s.) was stressing the importance of the night prayer and urging them to rise for it."
Minah-276:
When we were with him in Bitlis, it was being said among the people that a scholar who was a fierce denier of the Sufis had sent a man in a state of major ritual impurity to Ghawth (k.s.) for the purpose of examining and testing him. A few days later it came up in the exalted gathering. Ghawth (k.s.) said: "What kind of test is this? Does the tester not know that the miracles and disputations of the Naqshbandis are hidden, like their other works? Ghawth (k.s.) thereby indicated that he was aware of that dispute and had answered the disputant, but that the disputant was not aware of this answer."
Minah-277:
A servant says: "Ghawth (k.s.) told me, naming her, that he thought it suitable for me to marry a certain woman. I said, had Ghawth (k.s.) not said of her, 'I do not like her, she is ill-omened'?" Ghawth (k.s.) said: "At that time I said that. Now I say this."
On this command I married that woman and saw her blessing."
Minah-278:
One of the sufis related this event: "A stray thought (khatir) came to my heart and troubled me for three days. During that time Ghawth (k.s.) never mentioned the stray thought. After the three days, Ghawth (k.s.) turned to me and said: 'A murid who cannot repel a stray thought is not fit to be accepted as a murid.' After these words it was as though the stray thought had never been. The sufi continued: "Ghawth (k.s.) said to one of the sufis: how do you know such-and-such a scholar? He says heedlessness never comes to him. The sufi answered:
-"It is possible, there is no end to the bounty of God (Exalted is He).
-He said to me:
-"What do you say?"
-I said:
-"In my opinion that scholar does not know heedlessness. Ghawth (k.s.): -"So it is," he said.
Minah-279:
Ghawth (k.s.) said that he had visited Haji Musa Efendi of Bitlis, one of the khalifas of the Nuriye tariqa, and had met him in his garden weeding wild plants and hoeing around the tree roots, and that when he saw him he said: "Without being shamed, and without feeling regret and embarrassment; some heedlessness is mercy." It is said that of this person Ghawth (k.s.) would say: "If I had not seen Seyyid Taha (k.s.), I would have become his murid."
Minah-280:
Ghawth (k.s.) related that he asked the shaykh named in the above minah "who his shaykh was," and that he replied: "My shaykh was a majdhub, the one famous as Shaykh Çıblak-ül Ahlaki. This person's outward was indeed ruined, that is, not adorned with the outward beauties of the sacred law. Yet in reality he had a flourishing inward."
Minah-281:
Ghawth (k.s.): "Haji Musa Efendi asked me about my tariqa. I said: 'I am Naqshbandi.' Then Haji Musa Efendi (k.s.) said: Naqshibandu, Naqshibandu, Naqshiband (naqshibandu: the person who binds his heart to the name of God (Exalted is He)) Grieving, grieving, grieving…
Ghawth (k.s.): "I suppose Haji Musa Efendi was pointing to three trials and three narrow mountain paths (aqaba) ahead of me in the tariqa. And it turned out as he said. Such is the word of the great." he said.
Minah-282:
Ghawth (k.s.), I suppose to point out that doing injustice is by no means good and that places are affected by the outpouring (fayd) of the masters, said: "Molla Taha (k.s.), one of the great khalifas of our shaykh, known as Köse Halife, used to swear that the village of Nehir, except for the emir's fortress and the Jewish quarter, had become light, its stones, its earth and everything in it."
Minah-283:
Ghawth (k.s.) said that one day during a visit to his shaykh, he went to the tomb of the shaykh's uncle Seyyid Abdullah (k.s.). At that time his shaykh Seyyid Taha (k.s.) had come for tawajjuh. Not finding Ghawth (k.s.), he searched for him. When Ghawth (k.s.) came to him, he scolded him and said: "Have you come here for graves?"
Minah-284:
Ghawth (k.s.) says: "After the death of our shaykh Seyyid Taha (k.s.), his brother Shaykh Salih succeeded to his post (the seat of spiritual authority). During his talks he recited this couplet:
'A living cat is better than a dead lion.'
Ghawth (k.s.): 'In some vision I saw Seyyid Taha (k.s.). He said, Salih counts me as dead. Yet I have not died.'"
Minah-285:
When Ghawth (k.s.) strongly forbade one of his companions to listen to musical instruments, that person, dressing up his desire as something fair, related in the gathering what one of the scholars of the outward, who make major sins seem trivial by citing verses and hadiths that point to hope, had said: "What harm is there in listening to musical instruments, since the listener, after listening, says 'there is no god but God' and is freed of his sin." The narrator says: Ghawth (k.s.) became very angry. He said: "May his eyes go blind. When the one who burns from the floor (the four elements) to the Throne (the lata'if) says this good word, his sin goes away."[43]
Minah-286:
A sufi said: One day Ghawth (k.s.), tired of his companions, did not come out to the exalted gathering. He said:
"Because they do not know the manners of suhba, they are harmed by suhba. For they do not hold suhba among themselves so as to learn the manners. In truth, the suhba among themselves teaches the manners of the suhba in the presence."
Minah-287:
Ghawth (k.s.) said: "The Naqshbandi tariqa may not impose the burden and heaviness of the ascetic disciplines found in other tariqas. But its murid must be more careful than the murids of others in avoiding acts and innovations that the sacred law does not accept." The narrator says: "I said, by what should the murid know what is contrary to the sacred law, so as to protect himself?" Ghawth (k.s.) answered: "The scholar by his knowledge, and the ignorant…" The poor one (Halid-i Öleki (k.s.)) adds: I have forgotten whether the narrator said "by the heart" or "by the smarting of the nafs."
Minah-288:
Ghawth (k.s.) one day asked me (Halid-i Öleki (k.s.)): "Does the rabita teach you anything?" "Yes," I said. He said to me: "Write it." Because I feared I could not do full justice to obeying it, that command weighed on me. As was his custom, being aware of what came to the heart, he sensed this. "It is not a command." he said.
Minah-289:
During one of Ghawth (k.s.)'s visits to Uways al-Qarani (may God be pleased with him), he met a person who claimed to be a khalifa of this path, and indicated that he should accompany him to the tomb of Uways (may God be pleased with him) and attend at his exalted stirrup. That claimant of khalifate did not obey the command. Later that claimant swore to some of his own companions: "I flew just now, visited the tomb and returned. The shaykh did not know of this." I suppose he implied to his companions that, since he was able to travel by flying, he had not followed the indication. Ghawth (k.s.) heard of this claim. He said to me (Halid-i Öleki (k.s.)): "Some say so. If this is true, it is from Satan. If it is a lie, that claim is like the dervishes' shaykhdom among the people of the tents (the nomads)."
Minah-290:
Ghawth (k.s.) said: "When I was with Muhiddinüs Sahra (k.s.), I used to visit the tomb famous as Mahammed-ül Gavs Meşhedi (k.s.). One day, as I was visiting it, a state came upon me there. As I was returning from the tomb, Muhiyyiddin-üs Sahra (k.s.) said to me: 'Where have you been?' 'To the tomb,' I said. He said to me: 'From this day on you will receive no benefit from me.'"
Minah-291:
Ghawth (k.s.) mentioned that in his early days on the path he used to go back and forth to Halid-i Cizrevi (k.s.) and said: "A person who knew the past and present state of our family said to me: 'What a strange thing: the world comes to your house to receive benefit. You go to other doors.' I said to the man: 'If a person's vessel is empty, he must suffer hardship.'"
Minah-292:
Between the exalted threshold and the house of the poor one (Halid-i Öleki (k.s.)) there was a distance of about one day. On one of my visits I spent five days on the road. When I reached the hidden treasure and sat in the exalted gathering, Ghawth (k.s.) reproached me: "How many days is it since you left home? Why were you late?" When I said, "Five days," he turned his face from me.
Minah-293:
I suppose Ghawth (k.s.) pointed out that the murid should prefer all that belongs to his shaykh over what belongs to others. Within the minah there is an indication that Ghawth (k.s.) was in the station of ghawthiyya. Namely, some of the people of Shirvan complained to me (Halid-i Öleki (k.s.)) that they feared that some of the aghas of Hizan would encroach on the boundaries of their pastures. To protect the Shirvanis, my fellow townsmen, I said: "I will not allow anyone other than those in the retinue of Ghawth (k.s.) to encroach." When the exalted gathering was formed, Ghawth (k.s.) turned to me and recited this couplet:
"Do not find fault with Nushirwan, for the seven lands are the mole on your face."
Then Ghawth (k.s.) said: "To my mind, at that time the qutb of all was in Shiraz."
Minah-294:
One of his companions relates: We visited Uways al-Qarani with Ghawth (k.s.). On the first day we performed the Khatm-i Khwajagan facing the tomb. On the second day, when the time of the khatm came, Ghawth (k.s.) said: "He is a saint of solitude. He does not like such things." and forbade the khatm. And he said: "Whoever visits Uways al-Qarani, let him be content with turning toward him and asking for help."
Minah-295:
One of the followers says: "I visited a tomb with Ghawth (k.s.). After Ghawth (k.s.) had stayed in muraqaba in the tomb for an hour, when he came out onto the porch, there was irritation and anger upon him. Then he turned to the keeper of the tomb, who was performing audible dhikr there, and said: "Do you not know that the one lying here is a Naqshbandi? He does not approve of audible dhikr being performed."
Minah-296:
One of his murids: "We went with Ghawth (k.s.) to visit a place known as the tomb of a great one. When Ghawth (k.s.) had visited the tomb and come out, a sufi went in and sat in muraqaba. When he rose, because of a sweet state that came to him, he praised the owner of the resting place. By this praise he meant to say that the place was a tomb. Ghawth (k.s.) said: "This is not a tomb but rather the station of that saint. Very few of the saints who visit sacred places can tell whether those places are a station or a tomb."
Minah-297:
Ghawth (k.s.) said: "In truth I attained the station of fana in all five lata'if. Saints who are annihilated in all of them are rare."
Minah-298:
One of the community of murids relates: "We had gone to Bitlis with Ghawth (k.s.), and as we passed along the road we met the emir of Hizan. When Ghawth (k.s.) had moved a little aside, the emir brought a purse of silver coins.
He wished to give it to Ghawth (k.s.). But the master did not accept.
The narrator says: "A friend and I secretly took that purse, thinking we would spend it for Ghawth (k.s.). Then, thinking that the saints are aware of what is in the heart, we continued on our way in fear. When we caught up with the company, we saw that the murids were sitting by a stream, gathered in a ring around Ghawth (k.s.). As soon as he saw us he became severely angry and said harsh words: 'Are you accepting the emir's bounty?' We were very afraid of this situation.
My friend was one of his close servants. The master insisted that we give this gift back. However much the other murids interceded for us, it was of no use.
Then it crossed my heart: the emir has taken from my property more than a hundred times the value of this gift. So I took this not for the shaykh but for myself.
The narrator says: After his anger had passed and he fell silent, he no longer told us to give the gift back.
The poor one (Halid-i Öleki (k.s.)) says: "His anger's stopping and his falling silent was because he attributed the event, God (Exalted is He) knows, to the matter of zafar[44]. Ghawth (k.s.)'s exalted character traits were such that when he found a way to interpret something that looked objectionable in a sound sense, he would keep silent like this."
Minah-299:
One of the murids related. Ghawth (k.s.) said: "When I first entered the tariqa, I could recognize when doubtful food came into the house. Then I became such that I could recognize it when it was set before me. Later I could recognize it when I took it into my mouth."
The narrator says: "After this Ghawth (k.s.) often asked his kin about the food set before him."
Minah-300:
Ghawth (k.s.) related this event from his shaykh Seyyid Taha (k.s.):
The outward meaning: two rak'as of prayer performed with the tooth-stick are better than seventy rak'as performed without the tooth-stick.[45] But when he recited it, he would read the kaf with a fatha, taking it as addressing someone, and would take the word "siwa" as the exceptive particle ("other than"). Then Ghawth (k.s.) would say to this poor one (Halid-i Öleki (k.s.)): "Does the wording of the hadith allow for this indication?" When I said I did not know, Ghawth (k.s.) said: "But our shaykh Seyyid Taha (k.s.) used to recite it this way." I (Halid-i Öleki (k.s.)) say: when he asked, I did not know the reason for the indication. Later, at some times it came to my heart that the address in the indication is to God (Exalted is He). And in truth that is the right aspect. In reality, it is with the contemplation of the "siwa" (everything other than God (Exalted is He)), the one contemplating being the one who prays: he stands before the Creator who is the owner of the command, like the standing of one who makes supplication, who whispers entreaty, and who has fled and been caught and taken captive. Besides this, he contemplates the states that befall those who pray and that differ from one another by the difference of views. The "siwa" that is contemplated is the world. Namely: they are those who worship the Lord and ask His help. Among them, one who attained that blessing, and one who deserved wrath and fell into that humiliation. Furthermore, two rak'as prayed while reflecting on the states to which the prayer points by word and essence are better than seventy rak'as prayed in pure presence (huzur-i mahz) that makes the thought of anything besides God (Exalted is He) absent. For in the first there is the fulfillment of the reality of the prayer. The second is not so. After the death of Ghawth (k.s.) I discussed this indication with one of the murids. He decided in accordance with what had come to my heart above. And he strengthened this decision with the saying he narrated from Ghawth (k.s.): "For people of the tariqa, presence in prayer is easy. But presence as the sacred law requires is hard." I praised God (Exalted is He) for his agreement. Only my heart was not at rest with the form and statement that had come to my heart. For a time I was hesitant until there came to my heart: "The address in the indication is to the one praying." The explanation of this is: "To be in presence for two rak'as while not being in prayer is better than seventy rak'as of prayer performed while not being in presence." My heart was illumined by this and found peace. Although the first form is subtler. God willing, in the Lama' we shall explain that the second form is preferred, and that the first is remote in both wording and meaning.
Minah-301:
Once, after staying four months at the exalted threshold, I asked leave to return home. Ghawth (k.s.): "Tomorrow I will go to a town, be patient and we will go together." The town that Ghawth (k.s.) named was exactly on my way. It was about a mile away. The next day the rain began from morning. It continued until late forenoon. It came to my heart: if only the rain would stop we could go. Then I was made to forget this stray thought. As the divine word says: يَوْمَ يَبْعَثُهُمُ اللّٰهُ جَم۪يعًا فَيُنَبِّئُهُمْ بِمَا عَمِلُواۜ اَحْصٰيهُ اللّٰهُ وَنَسُوهُۜ وَاللّٰهُ عَلٰى كُلِّ شَيْءٍ شَه۪يدٌ۟On the Day Allah resurrects them all together, He will then inform them of what they have done. Allah has kept account of it all, while they have forgotten it. For Allah is a Witness over all things. (Al-Mujadilah 58:6, Diyanet) Shortly afterwards Ghawth (k.s.) graciously came down. And sitting in this poor one's cell for nearly an hour, while talking on the science of gnosis, at one point he said these words that had no connection with what he had been saying: "Now my little six-year-old daughter is saying, if only the rain would go on and my father would not go." I (Halid-i Öleki) did not understand the indication in this saying until I left his exalted presence. Then it came to my heart. Ghawth (k.s.) was with this saying warning me of that bad stray thought. For my wishing for the rain to stop, even indirectly, meant wishing for separation from the beloved. Yet the true lover does not want to be apart from the beloved even in his dreams. Because of this feeling he reproached me, saying: "The himmat in you has not reached the degree of a girl just weaned from milk." And he reproached me: "The himmat in you has not reached the degree of a girl just weaned from milk."
When I realized my state, I was shamed in a way no one knew but God (Exalted is He).
Ghawth (k.s.) had such a disposition that, when disclosing a stray thought would put the one whose heart it had crossed to shame, he would veil my understanding as he alluded to it, and let me grasp it only after I had left.
If there was to be no shaming, he would make it known while still in the gathering.
How exalted is God (Exalted is He), who gave him the power of disposition over hearts and made him an educator of hearts in the most wise manner and the most sought-after way.
I swear that Ghawth (k.s.) was a muqallib. That is, he had the quality of changing the bad acts in hearts into good. He was a pure polish that could enter between a person and his heart (in whom this attribute appeared brilliantly)[46]. In sum; Ghawth (k.s.) was a perfect and shining mirror. A ladder that raised one up to the highest station. I should have deferred such words to the Lama'. But since my longing overcame me, I mentioned it here.
Minah-302:
Ghawth (k.s.) one day praised Mevlana Haji Hakkari (k.s.), one of the khalifas of his shaykh Seyyid Taha (k.s.): "When he set out on the road, he took his horse along with him and never rode it." Then, as if citing proof of his not riding: "He was truly an abdal." (one of the seven) he said.
I (Halid-i Öleki) said that he had a child and that I had seen in some books that abdals have no children. Ghawth (k.s.): "That saying is groundless." he said.
Minah-303:
Ghawth (k.s.) used to praise very much Mevlana Süleyman Beradesti (k.s.), one of the khalifas of his shaykh Seyyid Taha (k.s.). And he would say: "Is it because he continually progressed in the station of the unity of being (wahdat al-wujud) that the tariqa did not spread through him and people did not benefit from him? Or because his homeland was near the shaykh's? I do not know."
Minah-304:
Ghawth (k.s.) said: My shaykh Seyyid Taha (k.s.) was asked, "Who is there in the village of Nehir as a murid?" He answered: "The person called Kambur Molla Muhammed." In response to this saying of Seyyid Taha (k.s.): "That person's temper is very harsh," they said. Seyyid Taha (k.s.) said: "Let it be," and recited this couplet belonging to Mevlana Ahmed-i Cizrevi:
"The people of the tariqa, of all kinds, in their journeys are like the stations.
Sometimes majesty, sometimes beauty, their heads were inside the cup of wine."
Minah-305:
One of the sufis related. Ghawth (k.s.) said: "Let no one perform supererogatory acts without taking permission from a shaykh. If he cannot find a shaykh, let him perform them and benefit."
Minah-306:
Ghawth (k.s.) said: "One of the khalifas of our shaykh said to our shaykh:
If only the shaykh would go on pilgrimage. Since our shaykh lacked bodily strength, he had appointed one of his khalifas as deputy to perform the pilgrimage in his place. But the other khalifas did not approve of that khalifa's word and did not consider it acceptable."
Minah-307:
I suppose Ghawth (k.s.) pointed out: A sensible person should regard as a prize the opportunities in the states and stations that open to him and hasten to fulfill what they require. Especially if it is new knowledge, if it is worth writing down, if its benefit is general, if it is not among the matters that must be kept hidden, one must hasten to record it so that the benefit from it may be completed, lest it slip away. Let no laxity be shown in recording it, lest it be lost. Often its coming is from the particularities of that time, the scents of that place or the reflection of the person he talked with, and so on. When that person leaves, that state may not be obtained again. Let him not be deceived into thinking, I will remember it again, or trust his nafs that it will come to my heart when I wish. This is the reason for what is written. Praise and thanks be to God (Exalted is He), blessing and peace be upon our Prophet Muhammad the Chosen (peace be upon him), upon his family and his Companions. [42 This is an indication that the saints' relation (nisba) is not cut off by death] [43 Ghawth (k.s.)'s intent: to point out that the sin of the person who is unaware in the dominion and realm of spirits from the ground to the Throne, and who burns only with the love of the Exalted Truth (Exalted is He), is removed when he says the good word "there is no god but God," whereas the sin of one who, while saying the good word with his tongue, has a thousand and one kinds of stray thoughts in his heart, is not forgiven.] [44 Zafar: in the Shafi'i school, it is the permissibility of taking, of whatever falls into one's hand, the amount of one's property, that is, its value, whether of the same kind as one's property or of another kind. Although the original position of the Hanafi school is that one may take only of the same kind as one's property, today's fatwa is like the Shafi'i. Ibn Abidin, Kitab al-Sariqa 3/200, Beirut edition.]
[45 Fayd al-Qadir 4/36-4446]
[46 Surah al-Anfal, verse 24]

