Can Damlaları

Minah [241-270]

Minah-241:

Ghawth (k.s) said: "Persisting in negation and affirmation (nafy and ithbat) and multiplying it increases the effect and benefit of suhba on people."

Minah-242:

Ghawth (k.s), saying that the descent of manifestations (tajalliyat) is greater in seeing oneself as poor and observing one's fault than in presence (huzur), related from one of the Sadat: "I noticed my deficiency only through the descent of manifestations."
This saying is one that cuts at the root the vein of self-deception through states that are exceedingly fine and subtle.

Minah-243:

Ghawth (k.s) said that his sheikh Sayyid Taha (k.s) said "What the murid receives from his sheikh through rabita and vision (waqi'a) is stronger than what he receives from him by word of mouth." A faqir said: "How is it known whether advancement is from the sheikh or from Satan?" Ghawth (k.s) said: "He measures it by the Shariah; if it concerns suluk, he weighs it by the pillars of the tariqa, and sometimes he repeats what he has learned three times. It is also known by the manner in which the nisba comes. If the nisba comes from four directions, he knows that it is true." Indeed in this last case there is no question of Satan's dominion. It was asked again: Does a nisba that comes during sleep remain with the murid? Ghawth (k.s) answered: "No regard is given to dreams."


Minah-244:

Ghawth (k.s) was asked: "Does the murid make the rabita of a person other than his sheikh whose rabita brings benefit?" He answered: "No." Khalid-i Uleki (k.s) says: In another assembly I heard Ghawth (k.s) relate from his own sheikh: "When we see a person whose rabita brings benefit, make his rabita." Then I (Khalid-i Uleki (k.s)) said: Should it be anyone whose rabita brings benefit, or must he be one of the sheikh's followers? He answered:
"Let him be of the sheikh's followers." This difference is attributed to a difference of time, or the first is taken as his own preference and the second as related from his sheikh. Or the unrestricted first statement is to be read as restricted by the second. My heart inclines more to this last.

Minah-245:

The ways in which the sheikhs came to give khilafa to some persons who had not reached the station of perfection and completion Ghawth (k.s) explained as follows: "For some saliks, reaching perfection and completion, by their nature, depends on their being given the khilafa and on their keeping suhba with those who will take nisba from them. Such persons turn to the sheikh because of their difficulties. These difficulties are sometimes resolved by rabita." I think that Ghawth (k.s), pointing to a second aspect, said: "When time is too short for his completion, the sheikh gives him the khilafa and recommends the suhba of the person who will bring him to perfection." To explain this, Ghawth (k.s) mentioned that at the end of his life Shah-i Naqshband (k.s) gave the khilafa to Yaqub-i Charkhi (k.s) and recommended to him the suhba of Ala al-Din-i Attar (k.s).

Minah-246:

I think that Ghawth (k.s), to point out that in some respects the rabita of the person whose rabita brings benefit is to be preferred to the wird, said: "Sometimes the murid of a wird sheikh (one who guides by the wird), though he continues his wird, cannot advance, does not rise, and turns back; but the murid of a rabita sheikh, so long as sincerity continues, does not decline."

Minah-247:

I think that, indicating from the sheikhs' joy in exercising authority (tasarruf) that place has importance in the influence on murids and in their advancement, and that this importance is gained only by being honored through the tasarruf of the friends of God, Ghawth (k.s) said: "In past times, because a community of the exalted and righteous exercised authority in the city of Bitlis, the advancement of murids in this land was swifter." And they related that his sheikh Sayyid Taha (k.s) preferred the village of "Berasar" in that land over the village of "Nehir" because a saint exercised tasarruf there, "since in the first (the village of Berasar) the nisba appears much."

Minah-248:

Ghawth (k.s) used to prefer seeing deficiency in oneself and observing one's fault to the continuance of presence (huzur).

Minah-249:

I think that Ghawth (k.s), pointing out that the presence of a denier in the suhba assembly prevents some of the congregation from benefiting from the suhba, meaning a denier who was also deaf, said: "If so-and-so had not been there, this suhba would have affected so-and-so."

Minah-250:

One day Ghawth (k.s) said: "A few years after her death I saw in torment a woman who for a long time used to come and go among us; that is, her state in the world of images was shown and made clear to us: 'That woman was not sincere,' and her coming and going was for other reasons. I also saw a man in torment. This person had a sincere son, but he himself was neither sincere nor a denier. I, this humble faqir (Khalid-i Uleki), became distressed when I understood that being with the sheikhs while remaining between sincerity and denial is harmful and ruinous. Yet I had believed the contrary of this, and that in this matter the saints are not like the Prophets (peace be upon them). After suffering distress for about three hours, Ghawth (k.s) called me and said: 'I checked; the man who was with us and was seen in torment was a person of bad character.' After this answer my distress lessened. Ghawth (k.s), continuing from his previous word, said: 'Are the grains of the threshing floor trodden by cattle to be judged impure and pardoned out of necessity (this is so according to the Shafi'i school), or are they not to be judged impure at all?' Then he said: Concerning whether it is impure, I was told, 'Talk about impurity is idle.' Even by conjecture I could not understand what he meant by this, what he wished or what he was pointing to. God (Exalted is He) knows.

[37 For one who returns from fana to baqa, called marju', if permission for guidance is given with his return, this is called khilafa by indication. That is, the permission to guide is given not by his own sheikh alone but with the agreement and indication of the whole silsila. Of course at the head of them is the Prophet, our Master (peace be upon him), and indeed God Almighty (Exalted is He). A khalifa who has a general permission of this kind accepts murids as he wishes for as long as he lives. Since the khilafa of Imam Rabbani (k.s) was of this kind, when he accepted murids he did not perform istikhara. One who has received the khilafa by indication has no need to take permission from his sheikh for guidance. Even so, for some wisdom, he sometimes renews permission from his murshid. A khalifa who has finished his sayr-i suluk and has taken permission not from the Sadat but from his murshid is bound by his sheikh's command. If his sheikh wishes, he gives him a general permission. He may say, let him give repentance (tawba) to whomever he wishes. Or he may command: perform istikhara, investigate the murid's state, then give tawba. Khalifas of this type cannot go beyond the form their sheikh commanded. Even if a khalifa of this type returns from fana to baqa and reaches the highest station, he cannot go beyond the instruction he received from his sheikh. And God knows best.]

[38 The suhba meant here is companionship and being together.]
[39 Surat al-Isra, verse 81]
[40 When the murid first enters the tariqa, he supposes that there is no one greater than his own sheikh. But after the bond of discipleship has been established, God (Exalted is He) lets him know that another sheikh is more perfect than his sheikh. Because the murid's bond of discipleship has been established and because he benefits from his sheikh, he need not go to that more perfect one. Indeed the condition of surrender is to believe that guidance is only with one's own murshid. It is not a condition of surrender to believe that no one is greater than one's murshid. And God knows best.] [41 In this minhah Ghawth (k.s) gives a measure for distinguishing whether the states in a vision (waqi'a) are from the sheikh or from Satan. If the state in the vision relates to a jurisprudential ruling, it is measured by the Shariah. If it relates to suluk, it is weighed by the tariqa. If it cannot be understood by these, it is known to be from the sheikh by the repetition of the arriving state three times or by its occurring in an all-encompassing manner.]

Minah-251:

One day they said to Ghawth (k.s), meaning one who had newly become a murid: "That person was with a denier yesterday." Ghawth (k.s) went out in haste and said to that murid in the exalted assembly: "Choose either being a murid or keeping company with deniers! …" At this word the newly made murid apologized, saying, "They are my old friends, I have not seen them for six years." Thereupon Ghawth (k.s) said: "A denier must be left, even if he be a brother." Then, as mentioned in the previous minhahs, he spoke at length of the harms of being with deniers. They also related an incident that occurred. This had happened to Khalid-i Jazarawi (k.s), a suhba sheikh: I took the tariqa from a khalifa of our Master Khalid-i Baghdadi (k.s), the sheikh of sheikhs, who had come to Jazira. By the blessing of his first tawajjuh I became a possessor of unveiling of hearts (kashf al-qulub). After leaving him I went to the madrasa. I kept suhba with the denier students. I saw that after the suhba with these deniers the state I had had left me. Ghawth (k.s), saying that there is a difference between one who denies out of ignorance and one who denies out of envy, said "being with the first is not like the second in respect of harm." (That is, the harm of one who denies out of envy is greater.)

Minah-252:

As I understood, Ghawth (k.s) said that just as one who is a follower (muqallid) in the jurisprudence of a school (one who practices that school), since for a long time he has lacked the power to derive rulings from the texts, must act according to the school of the one he follows and not depart from his school by deriving rulings from the texts (the Book, the Sunna, consensus, analogy), so one who is in a tariqa, in matters of etiquette, "so long as the traces of the tariqa's pir or of the khalifas followed remain," must follow them and should not seek etiquette from the texts and the works of the past sheikhs. A person wished to kiss his foot in the exalted assembly; although Ghawth (k.s) forbade him, he would not let go. Ghawth (k.s) said to a Sufi: "Why do you not stop him?" The Sufi: "Why should I stop him?" Ghawth (k.s) said: "Because it is an innovation (bid'a)." The Sufi cited the hadith: "The Prophet (peace be upon him) permitted a man who asked permission to kiss his hand; permitted him who asked permission to kiss his foot; but when he asked permission to prostrate, the Prophet did not permit it." Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) related that neither his own sheikh Sayyid Taha nor any of the earlier khalifas of this tariqa had allowed their feet to be kissed and that they forbade those who acted so.

Minah-253:

One day in the exalted assembly mention was made of a strong denier among the outward scholars, his bad belief was described, and how the people accused him in his religion.
Ghawth (k.s) said to a Sufi: "Have you not heard the saying of Hazrat Shah (Shah-i Naqshband (k.s)), 'whoever turns away from our tariqa is in danger of perishing in his religion'?"

Minah-254:

Ghawth (k.s) said: "For the sheikhs of guidance, the conquest of honored places is difficult." Then he asked one of the Sufis the wisdom of this; the Sufi said: "I do not know, but the difficulty of the conquest of Mecca fits this minhah." Ghawth (k.s) fell silent and did not speak.
Ghawth (k.s) again said one day: "The townspeople, because heedlessness has overtaken them, are affected later than the villagers."

Minah-255:

Ghawth (k.s) said: "When a murid from among the common people becomes affiliated, he understands the worth of this attachment and of the breath of the sheikhs, and the benefit he has seen, only in the hereafter." A man of unveiling of our time passed by a graveyard and saw that some people were in torment and a few in bliss. He had his murids ask what the deeds of those in bliss had been… In reply, meaning a sheikh of their time, they said nothing but: "We were murids of Sheikh Nasir."

Minah-256:

Ghawth (k.s) said: "Sometimes a salik is permitted by God (Exalted is He) to guide. But his sheikh does not indicate to him that he is permitted. In response to these words of Ghawth (k.s) the Sufis asked:
"What then is the state of that salik?" Ghawth (k.s) said: "People benefit from him, his suhba is effective." But he said nothing about whether such a salik may undertake the duty of guidance and take murids. Ghawth (k.s) said: "In an ignorant murid too, just as in a learned salik, the stations of fana and baqa are realized. When these states are realized, benefit is seen from his inner being too and his suhba is effective."

Minah-257:

Ghawth (k.s), saying that backbiting of deniers is of three kinds, said it is not fitting to mention two of these kinds here, and explained the third thus: "Backbiting of the deniers is permissible in order to protect one's brothers from them." The Naqshbandi Sheikhs would always adduce as proof of the permissibility of backbiting the deniers that the Companions (may God be pleased with them) had reviled the unbelievers in satire. Khalid-i Uleki (k.s): I suppose he did not consider it fitting to mention the two groups of deniers at that place. This minhah requires commentary; we have left it to the Lem'a.

Minah-258:

I think that Ghawth (k.s), to indicate that he forbade the permissibility of accepting help (begging in hunger) of the kind that is istishraf hukmi (istishraf in effect, that is, expecting something to be given through the manner of one's state), like true istishraf, said: "On a journey that I made for guidance, I was the guest of a few of the great ones of the world; they offered me some goods and some money as help; I did not accept." A Sufi asked the reason. I suppose that the Sufi asked so because the conditions were present. These great ones of the world had made it a custom to give something to sheikhs and scholars when they were their guests. They would not give anything without going to the poor or being visited by them. Then Ghawth (k.s) told a story reporting that being the guest of a people who give help, even if not for the sake of help, counts as istishraf hukmi.

Minah-259:

Ghawth (k.s) said: "I refused the gift of some people and their sincerity increased. I refused the gift of another and his sincerity decreased and his rank fell." When he was asked the reason, Ghawth (k.s) answered: "The first were attached to the world; their giving was from constraint (takalluf; that is, they felt obliged). When a person's beloved is returned to him, his love increases. The second group's giving was from innate (jibilli) generosity. When what a man dislikes is returned to him, he is repelled by it. Whereupon this humble faqir asked the reason why the sheikh did not accept his gift in order to preserve his sincerity. I think Ghawth (k.s), to indicate that even if the sheikh is bound to another he looks to the interest of the murid, provided only that it does not cause corruption, said:

"If I had accepted your gift, then when I refused the gifts of your neighbors, whose gifts cannot be accepted, their hearts would have been broken."

Minah-260:

One day in the exalted assembly mention was made of Khwaja Ahrar (k.s) accepting no gift at all from anyone, whoever it might be. Ghawth (k.s) said:
Sheikhs greater than Khwaja Ahrar (k.s) have accepted gifts. The benefit hoped for by refusing an acceptable gift can never equal the harm of the broken heart caused by turning away one who wishes to give a gift. Many times Ghawth (k.s) would speak words on this subject indicating that the gift should be limited to a small amount. That is, he would say "although there is corruption in taking gifts, it is accepted when the conditions are complete." In many instances, in refusing a gift that could be accepted, there is, more than breaking the said heart, insistence and obstinacy in what one has said. Then I think Ghawth (k.s), to indicate the reasons Khwaja Ahrar (k.s) and the like did not accept, said: "That is sometimes from station and sometimes from temperament (mashrab)."

Minah-261:

Ghawth (k.s) asked a faqir the reason for the fall of one of his khalifas of necessity who had been famous from the beginning for his righteousness. The faqir scholar answered: "He accepted the gift of some oppressors and laid hands on endowment (waqf) property. Besides doing these things, he opposed the Master of the Time (the Master of the Time is Ghawth (k.s)). This one matter alone is sufficient for the lowering of rank. Moreover that faqir scholar pointed out that the names of those who stood against Khwaja Ahrar (k.s) were lost and their traces erased." I think Ghawth (k.s), to indicate that all those mentioned depend on the lowering of rank and its outcome, and that in truth the cause is introducing innovation into the tariqa, which requires the cutting off of the exercise of authority by the sheikhs of the silsila, and that he is thus left alone with his self, said: "That person was performing audible dhikr in order to make himself loved by the sheikh of the Qadiri tariqa. Yet my sheikh Sayyid Taha (k.s) said: 'It is impossible to reach the goal by practicing in two tariqas at once. Only, if after suluk he wishes to enter another tariqa, he must return to the starting point of the road and begin the journey anew.'"

Minah-262:

Ghawth (k.s) said: "The presence in the saying of Abdulkhaliq Ghujdawani (k.s): 'Let your mind be in your breath' (that is, gather your mind in your breath, guard your heart from heedlessness with every entry and exit of your breath. Thus may your heart be in presence at all times) includes the rabita and presence and the other deeds that encompass presence and in the end return to presence."

Minah-263:

When Ghawth (k.s) gave a command whose purpose he had not explained clearly, if he feared that the addressee would interpret it as far as he understood from the outward form of what was said and act wrongly, he would correct his word. For example, a man who feared that his son would be conscripted came to him and asked for his himma (spiritual aid). Ghawth (k.s) said: "Leave your son to destiny." That man said, "Is the sheikh convinced that my son will be saved if I give something to some officials?" Ghawth (k.s) said: "Try that." Whereupon the man went out. After this Ghawth (k.s) said to a faqir: "Was what I told him not contrary to the Shariah?" The faqir scholar said: "The sheikh did not clearly command giving anything." But Ghawth (k.s) was not satisfied with this and sent this message after that man: "Give nothing to anyone, leave your son to the judgment of God (Exalted is He)." For some time afterward, signs of fear over that word could be seen on the face of Ghawth (k.s).

Minah-264:

One day in the exalted assembly mention was made of the emirs and khans of the city of Bitlis. One of those present mentioned a portion of their righteous deeds and piety. Ghawth (k.s) said: "That their emirates were taken from their hands before the emirates of the tribal chiefs of that region were taken is sufficient proof of their righteousness."

Minah-265:

A sincere friend related from Ghawth (k.s): "Whoever wishes his hair to turn gray early, let him be a shepherd (be a sheikh)."

Minah-266:

One of the Sufis relates: "Some people asked Ghawth (k.s) to exert his himma against some persons who deserved destruction." Ghawth (k.s): "Himma is a double-edged sword, it cuts with both sides" he said, and to forbid asking for himma at random, "is himma dried apple strewn on the ground?" he said.

Minah-267:

One of the Sufis complained to Ghawth (k.s) of what he suffered from love of a woman and named the woman. Ghawth (k.s) had the woman called and told her to marry him; the woman obeyed, saying she would marry, and only asked for time for some matters. I think Ghawth (k.s) perceived with insight that the woman's excuse was a pretext.
The Sufi says: "Ghawth (k.s) told me, for a few days while counting the wird, to keep my hand with the prayer beads there on my chest between the two breasts, and also to make rabita of my sheikh as sitting on my chest. When I kept this command for nearly fifteen days, my attachment to that woman left me. When I came to the exalted assembly, Ghawth (k.s) smiled and said something in the sense of 'we have no need of her favor.'"

Minah-268:

One of the Sufis says; One of his children asked Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) to have someone who deserved disgrace punished through his himma. Ghawth (k.s) rebuked him: "My son, himma is a double-edged sword, it cuts with both edges" he said, and also in the same sense "himma is not dried apple to be strewn about" he said.

Minah-269:

One day Ghawth (k.s) came out of the tawajjuh circle and said to one of the Sufis: "Go and tell so-and-so the Sufi to marry off his son, otherwise let his son not take part in the tawajjuh circle from now on." Then Ghawth (k.s) said: "That child was unmarried; because of his darkness I came near to being unable to complete the tawajjuh."

Minah-270:

One of the Sufis of Ghawth (k.s) related: One day my master sent me, together with my friend, to his Sheikh Sayyid Taha (k.s) on a courier's errand. A few days after reaching Sayyid Taha (k.s) I hurried to get the answer and return. Then Sayyid Taha (k.s) said in jest: "What is the matter with you? When you come with the khalifa you do not tire even in a year, but when you come alone you tire in a few days." Then he said to my friend humorously: "Tell the khalifa I have permitted him, let him strike this Sufi a few blows." When he reached Ghawth (k.s) my friend told the story. Ghawth (k.s):
-"Let me carry out my sheikh's command" he said, and struck me a few times with his blessed hand.

Back to the table of contents