Can Damlaları

Minah [181-210]

Minah-181:

One who has been realized in the station of sainthood must not be denied, whatever he does. In reality, what proceeds from them in a reprehensible form will turn into what is approved; but he indicated that in the world of trial, for the trial of the public, the return (to good) is sometimes hidden. The Ghawth (k.s.) pointed out that the hidden return (of the reprehensible to the approved) is to bring near doubting minds some of the universal forms (that tend toward other forms), and even to demand absolute confirmation without any reason. In explaining these forms he explained them in such an astonishing way that I think no one before him had explained them so collectively. The Ghawth (k.s.) hinted that the occurrence of that reprehensible act is one of those forms, for warding off the calamity of fame, which causes conceit (relying on one's deeds), takes away peace and draws various evils. While explaining these forms he mentioned that "a group of the saints are called 'Qalandariyya.' They cut off their beards, mustaches and eyebrows to hide themselves. Indeed one of the saints urinated on a tree among a crowd in such a way that it splashed on himself. Being in a state of sukr (spiritual intoxication) is also one of those forms. Just as intoxication from drink changes certain rulings, it is impossible that spiritual intoxication would not. The stories of Ibrahim-i Majdhub and Ali-i Shirazi (k.s.) are famous. There is the matter that Ali-i Shirazi (k.s.) seized two bags full of bread scraps from two beggars and ate what was inside. That the saints, while doing a reprehensible act, look at the world of archetypes (the spiritual world) and have their eyes closed to the world of witnessing (this world) is one of these forms. They see people in the form of the ugly and excessive evil attribute they have at that moment. Sometimes there (in the world of archetypes) they see them in the forms of women, and in the kind of another form among animals. They deal with them according to the requirements of those forms. There was a woman saint who walked among the people with her face and head uncovered. When she saw a perfect person, she would cover herself at once, saying "this is a man." The story concerning Hallaj-i Mansur's son Husayn and his daughter is famous: when Hallaj's daughter was asked why she covered half of her face and left half uncovered, she said: "I see half a man, and he is my brother."
One of those forms is also to repel the greatest evil with the lightest evil. The Ghawth (k.s.) said: "When the son of Shibli (k.s.) died, he too shaved his beard. When he was asked the reason, he said: the Almighty has promised me that He will not turn back whomever I pray good for. I feared the people would come to offer condolences to me. If I prayed for all of them, I would be going against the decree that has been written as wretchedness (absolutely) for some; and if I made a distinction among them, or left them all without prayer, their hearts would be broken, or it would cause speaking against me and similar mischiefs. This too is one of those forms; to tell what they do to bring about a great benefit tied to that reprehensible act, the Ghawth (k.s.) related this story: "A guest came to a sheikh in Ramadan. The sheikh, hoping that he would later follow him, followed him, broke his fast and ate with him. The murids left in disgust. After the meal the sheikh cut the prayer beads at his waist and said 'Just as I agreed with you in eating, you too follow me by cutting the priest's girdle (zunnar) at your waist.' The guest confessed and became a Muslim. Then the sheikh said to the murids: 'If I had not accompanied him, he would not have followed me either.' After this story the Ghawth (k.s.) said: "No evil comes from a person of gnosis. Although saints are not free from sin, sins are kept from harming them, and even if they have committed a sin, they do not incline by it from rightness to error."

Minah-182:

I think that the Ghawth (k.s.), pointing out that the clearest of the ways the sheikh knows should be shown to the murid, and alluding to the fact that progress occurs after death, said: "If Sheikh Abdulkhaliq Ghujdawani (k.s.) had known, while alive, what Shah-i Naqshband (k.s.) Hazrat received from his own spirituality in this Naqshbandi tariqa, he would have disclosed it in his lifetime and trained the murids with it.

Minah-183:

The perfect khalifas of a tariqa can make completing additions only when they are commanded to increase that tariqa. Regarding these additions, the khalifas must perform istikhara up to seven times.

Minah-184:

I think the Ghawth (k.s.) made the following point to remove the doubt in people's hearts that the tawajjuh well known among later sheikhs is an innovation in the tariqa that did not exist in the time of the earlier sheikhs. By this, hinting that a modification does no harm so long as it does not change the reality of the tawajjuh known in the time of earlier sheikhs, and that no regard is given to change of names, the Ghawth (k.s.) said: "Tawajjuh is a kind of gaze of attention well known among the ancients. The earlier sheikhs would do this gaze by facing each person one by one. They did not gather a congregation for this. The tawajjuh performed today must be accepted as a general gaze."
After these blessed words, I think the Ghawth (k.s.) indicated that the emergence of the present form of tawajjuh does not change the reality of tawajjuh. Pointing out that he had been commanded to perform tawajjuh in this way, he expressed, with the words "I have been strongly commanded to have tawajjuh performed in this way," that the noble masters attach great importance to it. Continuing his suhba on tawajjuh, he said: "Tawajjuh is the emptying of the murid's darkness by means of the light that the sheikh pours into him. Most of the time the murid does not perceive the state that occurs in him. For the common people tawajjuh is more beneficial than suhba; what afflicts them is repelled through tawajjuh. Indeed, even among the elect who share our disposition, tawajjuh is better. What the masters said about the gaze known in earlier times holds equally for tawajjuh. The two are one."

Minah-185:

Shah-i Naqshband (k.s.):
"Attachment to what is other than God is a great veil for the travelers of this path." he said. Binding the heart to anything other than God (Exalted is He) is a great curtain that keeps the righteous from reaching the Truth. The Ghawth (k.s.) would not read the wording but would relate the word to the word, in which case the meaning becomes thus:
Binding the heart to anyone other than a traveler of this path is a great veil. The Ghawth (k.s.) said that this couplet points to the station of guidance, and that since the murshid must busy himself with the training and teaching of the salik, the murshid's attachment to the salik is not a veil.

Minah-186:

Abdullah Dehlawi (k.s.) would greet some murids with praise and commendation. Whenever Mawlana Khalid-i Baghdadi (k.s.) came before him, he would honor him, saying "The dome of light has come." My sheikh Sayyid Taha (k.s.) did not greet murids like this, but rather described whomever he wished, in his absence, in his exalted state. The Ghawth (k.s.) too followed his sheikh in open praise. But he also praised some by allusion.

Minah-187:

The Ghawth (k.s.) often, in his exalted gatherings, told his murids of the perfections and virtues of persons who lived in his time or had lived earlier and whose sainthood had been disputed or remained hidden. We (Halid-i Öleki (k.s.)) think that by this the Ghawth (k.s.) was both showing his compassion to the people and forbidding speaking against such persons even if their sainthood was disputed or remained hidden. Indeed, one of his murids had weak sincerity regarding Sheikh Memduh-u Tillovi (k.s.). In a gathering where this murid was also present, the Ghawth (k.s.) related stories of the sheikh's perfections and sainthood. He continued these stories until the murid's sincerity toward the sheikh was complete.

Minah-188:

The Ghawth (k.s.), stating that the murid must avoid opposing his sheikh even in a good work, would relate that his sheikh Sayyid Taha (k.s) said: "I never opposed my sheikh Mawlana Khalid (k.s.) in anything, except that I opposed my sheikh by constantly giving food as long as murids were with him. Because my sheikh gave food for the three days of a guest's stay (as it was the sheikh's custom). I truly fear this opposition.".

Minah-189:

I think the Ghawth (k.s.), pointing out that the murid should not be satisfied that his sheikh's command is for a single time or a limited period but should interpret it as continuing as long as possible, said: "I did not oppose my sheikh's command except in two things. One of them: although he ordered me to wear trousers, I did not continue it."

Minah-190:

To express that the more the murid follows his sheikh in Islamic rulings and daily affairs, the more effect he sees, the Ghawth (k.s.), relating from his sheikh Sayyid Taha (k.s.), would say: "The effect of this tariqa is quicker among the Hanafis" and cite as proof, "The sheikhs of this tariqa were of the Hanafi school until the time of my sheikh Mawlana Khalid (k.s.)."

Minah-191:

The Ghawth (k.s.) , noting that the sheikhs of the last age do not speak about the tariqa as the ancients did, would explain the reason as follows. The founder of every craft and those after him speak (about the craft) only until the deficiency is made up, and when it is complete they see no need to give further opinion. Noting that the completeness of a craft is proof not of its having a deficiency but of its soundness, he said: –"The masters spoke of everything, they left no deficiency to be spoken of regarding the tariqa."

Minah-192:

Every deed has a particular trace. Through the trace the deed becomes manifest in the face. The perfect among the knowers recognize people's deeds from their faces. Even if among a congregation, when the sheikh asks the murid something, it is obligatory for him to tell the truth without fear of showing off (riya). When a lie is told, the sheikh can say to the murid "you are lying." An event carrying the matters described above occurred in the presence of the Ghawth (k.s.). He asked a murid who for a legitimate reason had not been able to come to visit for several years: "How was your rabita while you were not here?" The murid answered: "I was not doing rabita." The Ghawth (k.s.) said: "You are lying, because in truth your face is the face of rabita."

Minah-193:

God (Exalted is He) gives the sheikh certain perfections (in order that he may exercise tasarruf upon the murid). Thus the murid becomes the cause of the sheikh's progress. This is the reason that in the hagiographies of Yaqub-i Charkhi (k.s.) he is described as "the murid of Shah-i Naqshband (k.s.) and the sheikh of Ubaydullah-i Ahrar (k.s.)." If the sheikhhood of Yaqub-i Charkhi (k.s.) over Khwaja Ubaydullah (k.s) had not increased some of his perfections, there would have been no reason for mentioning the Khwaja in the account. A poor man asked: "Are these perfections given for exercising tasarruf upon the murid temporary and borrowed, or do they become the sheikh's property?" He answered: "They become the sheikh's property."

Minah-194:

A murid of Sayyid Taha (k.s.) complained to him of his human (metaphorical) love, whereupon my sheikh advised him: "Picture your sheikh in your imagination as being within your breast. In this way rabita erases metaphorical love."

Minah-195:

The salik sometimes reaches God (Exalted is He) through human love alone. The person afflicted with metaphorical love, burning through the effect of the love he is caught in, abandons love of the world. Now love of the world never returns to him.

Minah-196:

The Ghawth (k.s.) one day said, relating from some great ones, "in reality the metaphorical is the bridge of the real." A poor man said, "they commanded us not to stop on it, as a bridge requires, but to cross over it."
The Ghawth (k.s.); said "yes, but they are not equal in being benefited from". Halid-i Öleki (k.s.) says, "I did not truly understand this minha."

Minah-197:

Sayyid Qasim-i Tabrizi (k.s) is not one of the sheikhs of this silsila, but he shares in reward with Khwaja Ahrar (k.s.) and the Naqshbandi silsila after him.

Minah-198:

One of the khalifas of Sayyid Taha (k.s.) used to say to the murids "entrust your dhikr to rabita." But the Ghawth (k.s.) would say, if possible, "do rabita and dhikr together", that is, be constantly in rabita at the time of the wird.[34]

Minah-199:

Many of the Sufis who have not been given permission to guide and who live in a state of absorption (istighraq) are more perfect than the Sufis who have returned and been given permission to guide.

Minah-200:

There are three levels of giving khilafa. The first is the khilafa given by sign, considered the highest degree. The second is the khilafa given by word, which is the middle one. The third is the khilafa given in writing. This is the lowest level of giving khilafa.

[31 Surat al-Najm, verse 34]
[32 Surat al-Qalam, verse 10]
[33 A person who becomes drunk by drinking without knowing it is an intoxicant, or being forced by another, is not held responsible according to the Shafi'i and Hanafi schools. See Mughni al-Muhtaj 3/279, Beirut edition 1352 H.; Ibn Abidin, Durr al-Mukhtar 2/423, Egypt edition 1323 H.]

Minah-201:

The person with a wide spiritual throat has in his throat a hole both to receive the effusions and to give them to the murids. The effusions cannot clog his throat, that is, he does not fall into spiritual intoxication because of the fayz that comes. One with a narrow throat is clogged by a little fayz, falls into sukr, and cannot give to others.

Minah-202:

As the Ghawth (k.s.) Hazrat pointed out, no deed reaches the degree of jadhba. In terms of drawing near to God (Exalted is He) and gaining perfection, no deed can take the place of jadhba. Proofs such as clear texts and the unveiling of some saints express this truth. That some people of deeds come close in degree to the people of jadhba and compete with them in degree is due to the jadhba in their deeds. Continuing his words, the Ghawth (k.s.) said about a ghazi who had become a martyr: "I saw him in the world of archetypes with the standing of a perfect saint." My sheikh Sayyid Taha (k.s.) said: "A martyr from the common people was buried beside a great saint; I saw that that martyr was not lower than that saint." The Ghawth (k.s.) said: "Whether one becomes a martyr in battle or not, there is jadhba in battle; battle requires jadhba."

Minah-203:

The Ghawth (k.s.) was asked the wisdom of metaphorical love being rare in the Naqshbandi group: he said –"The jadhba that envelops this Naqshbandi group at the beginning makes them abandon all else and does not let them be concerned with anything other than God."

Minah-204:

The Ghawth (k.s.) one day said the following in an exalted gathering: "At the beginning, busying oneself with voluntary worship hinders jadhba and cuts the murid's speed."

Minah-205:

The Ghawth (k.s.) said: "Every sheikh, imperfect or perfect, sows a seed in the field of the murid's capacity. If an imperfect seed was sown earlier, the perfect one does not sow another seed on it until he has dried it up."

Minah-206:

Declaring that the most valuable place in which life is spent is the company of the perfect, and that a life not spent in such suhbas is as if never lived, the Ghawth (k.s.) said: "In a suhba I heard from my sheikh Muhyiddin-us Sahrani (k.s.): –"Holding the breaths prolongs life. Life is measured and determined by breaths." After hearing this word from my sheikh of suhba, I would hold my breath. Muhyiddin-us Sahrani (k.s) said: "The aim of life is suhba alone. Holding the breath prevents the perfection of suhba." The Ghawth (k.s.) asked a poor man; have you come to know that any of the reliable ancients said a word like the saying of Muhyiddin-us Sahrani (k.s.)? The poor man answered: "Yes, in the tafsir Ruh al-Bayan I saw something like this saying from certain verifying scholars, but I did not rely on it; rather I believed that, just as lives are bound by breaths, they are bound likewise by hours, days and the other parts of time. It is true that the view that life is bound by breaths alone was adopted to resolve the well-known difficulty about life lengthening and shortening. I think the Ghawth (k.s.), like his said sheikh, inclined to the first saying and said: "The rapid breathing in and out of a person in the state of death strengthens this."

Minah-207:

In reality, companionship dyes with the color of the companion, even if the one who keeps company is not pleased with that color or flees from it. Pointing out that this color will appear in the companion himself or in his followers even if they do not wish it, the Ghawth (k.s.) said: "The dhikr minshari (called the saw dhikr, which makes a sound in the throat like the sound a saw makes when cutting wood), seen in some of the newcomers to this exalted group, came to them from the companionship of Shah-i Naqshband (k.s.) with the Turkish sheikhs who performed this dhikr."

Minah-208:

In the exalted gathering the question was raised whether the dhikr minshari is by the sheikh's instruction or the murid's choice, or by jadhba and necessity. The Ghawth (k.s.) said: "The Turkish sheikhs taught it and did it willingly. Indeed it was in their tariqa." In the Naqshbandi tariqa, some beginners do it from an inner compulsion and necessity. The sheikh is free to exercise tasarruf upon them so that they are compelled to do it."

Minah-209:

The beginner's cry (sayha) arises when he passes from heedlessness to presence. If heedlessness or presence continues, this sound does not occur; the cry of those in the middle degree is because the fayz that comes does not fit in their chests. The Ghawth (k.s.), pointing out that the cries of some people are sometimes from the tasarruf of their sheikh, said: "Among the murids of some sheikhs there used to be great cries. The best example of the beginner's cry and presence is that when a green log is thrown into the fire, it makes a sound, and when the wood dries the sound stops."

Minah-210:

That those who have states such as laughing, weeping and crying out are called majdhub although they are not majdhub is only because a kind of jadhba is found in them when they pass from heedlessness to presence.

Return to the table of contents page