Minah [151-180]

Minah-151:
This minah is a great one. It might perhaps have been several minahs, but the ties between them have made them one. It should be considered separately in terms of the meanings that arise in this minah. This humble one read one of the letters from the Maktubat of Imam Rabbani (k.s.). I think he took delight in the letter. He was amazed at the ma'rifa in it. He found a little consolation. In a gathering at which this humble one was present, Hazrat Ghawth (k.s.) spoke on the taste of ma'rifa, which is one of the particular features of sainthood: "The taste of ma'rifa is a matter of inner consciousness. No expression can convey it. Ma'rifa taken from expression, even if it appears as a pleasant faculty, gives no benefit at all in the station of sainthood, just as a perfumed garment does not remove the bad smells inside the body. What counts in sainthood is, in reality, what is in the inner. What is in the outer is considered only after the inner, and only in the station of sobriety (sahw). In the state of intoxication (sukr) it is not considered at all. No saint can be a saint unless his inner is better than his outer." And he recited this couplet.
"Putting musk on your garment does not benefit you so much.
Inside the garment you have fallen into the smell of the armpit.
After this couplet he recited the line Hafiz of Shiraz spoke about Sheikh San'an: "Within the ring of the zunnar, he keeps the glorification and dhikr of the angels." I think that by reciting this couplet he indicated that when the lights of sainthood are realized in a person's inner, the outer form, which is seen like a garment over the inner, does no harm even if it differs from the forms required of other saints. This indication seems similar to the first indication (the minah that consideration is for the inner). I think that with this indication he hinted at a warning, so that the murid, reading the notebooks of these masters, such as the letters of Imam Rabbani (k.s.), should not fall into doubt about some perfections not outwardly found in his sheikh, should not have his sincerity shaken, and should not fall into suspicion about his sheikh. After the line above, the Ghawth (k.s.) said: "There is no innovation in clothing. Indeed the clothes of the later age differ from the clothes of the first age (the Age of Bliss). Innovation occurs only in acts of worship." This humble one was grieved at his fault because of the indication of Hazrat Ghawth (k.s.). Thereupon Hazrat Ghawth (k.s.) continued: "The sheikh points out to the murid his faults and deficiencies. So that the murid, seeing his deficiency and fault, may take refuge in his sheikh. The greatest aim of the state of contraction (qabd) is to take refuge in the sheikh. When the murid becomes aware of his state, he should meet the awareness arising in his heart with thanks and refuge. He must work hard to give up weariness with his sheikh because of the awareness in his heart. For this weariness is a great ingratitude and a deadly poison. God (Exalted is He) forbid, when weariness is reflected from his heart into the sheikh's heart, this state is eternal loss and misfortune." Hazrat Ghawth (k.s.) said: "Alauddin Attar (k.s.), though in the state of presence, was heedless of seeing it. In reality he was not heedless. The masters made him heedless so that he might obtain more. Abdulkhaliq Ghujdawani (k.s.) always knew that he was in presence. The masters did not make him heedless, so that he might seek more. Alauddin Attar (k.s.) was in sobriety (sahw). Ghujdawani (k.s.) was in effacement (mahw). Sobriety is more perfect than effacement. Nizamuddin Khamush (k.s.) forced himself into silence in order to draw presence. Yet he was in presence. Like Attar (k.s.), they made him heedless too. The heedlessness seen in these masters is not heedlessness. It appeared to them as heedlessness in the matter mentioned. In reality, when they are in presence they are annihilated. And the malady of heedlessness does not come to one who is annihilated. For them, the presence that is the goal is like the presence of the nafs for people. Often, even if a person is heedless of his nafs, his nafs is not heedless of him."
Then he warned that reading the works of the people of God would show seekers that there are very beautiful places above the station they are in, and that they should therefore turn toward them with longing. Through me (Khalid-i Öleki (k.s.)), Hazrat Ghawth (k.s.) was asked what the famous saying "Love of the homeland is part of faith" means. He gave the answer himself: "The places of the lata'if in the world of command are meant."
Minah-152:
A person cannot be a perfect human being unless there are two persons in him. "There is a human who, having traveled the path and left the body, goes out into the realm of dominion (malakut), then returns to the world of command. This is the human of the Hereafter.
The other human is the human of this world. He exists to live in this world." And saying this, they related the saying reported from Jesus (peace be upon him), "One who is not born twice cannot enter the realm of dominion."
Minah-153:
I think that to indicate that whoever enters the protection of a sheikh should be careful about his own nafs and cautious about that sheikh's murids, to explain also that courtesy toward the sheikh and his murids is necessary, so that the weak in the tariqa do not fall into despair but trust in the sheikh's himma, and so that the strong in the tariqa do not say "I am strong" but always fear the pride of their nafs, the Ghawth (k.s.) related the story of Khwaja Ahrar (k.s.) and Sa'duddin Kashghari (k.s.) from the time of their discipleship.
"In the time of their discipleship they were watching two wrestlers in a wrestling arena. They gave himma to these wrestlers in turn. The wrestlers defeated each other in turn. When the weaker wrestler defeated the stronger, the onlookers were amazed. But they could not understand the reason."
Himmat is found in murids as well. One who has such himma is worthy of permission to guide. Some murids, as in this story, test their own nafs to find out whether it has attained himma. Sometimes the sheikh tests them, as when Khwaja Ahrar (k.s.) one day sent his murids onto the wall of Samarkand and commanded them to use their himma for the breaking of Mirza Babur's army and the repelling of evil.
Minah-154:
To indicate that the himma of the elect and that of the common differ in origin, effect, and aim, the Ghawth (k.s.) said the following: "The origin of the first's himma is nisbas. The effect of this himma is certain and immediate. The second's is not so. The origin of his himma is prayer and deeds. Its effect and aim are different. The aim of the first is for the sake of religion, even if the religious side is hidden, as in the saint's vengeance. This vengeance is in truth not for the saint's own nafs but for a general or particular benefit." He confirmed these words with a story related from Sa'duddin Kashghari (k.s.): "One day Sa'duddin Kashghari (k.s.) was in muraqaba so that a sick person might find healing. A mouse in the ceiling several times let earth fall to the floor. Thereupon he rose. 'O discourteous one,' he said. At that moment a cat came and caught seventeen mice from that hole." For the second, whose aim is the world, he related this story: "A man worked for ten years to come upon a treasure. In the end he reached his aim." To point out how great the difference between the two himmas is, he recited the following couplet.
"The pulpit of Jesus (peace be upon him) is the heavens.
But the highest a preacher can climb is the pulpit."
Minah-155:
I think he said this to encourage entering the discipleship of a perfected sheikh, rather than being content with deficiencies that break the zeal that precedes the seeker's goal and spoil his readiness. "The murid's zeal is renewed only by having at least a general knowledge about the stations above the lofty states he is in. One who is deficient and poor in spirituality has no power to show the seeker the stations from afar." he said. The Ghawth (k.s.) continued: "When the one in whose heart no longing to reach the Beloved remains (one who has returned from fana to baqa) visits the graves of the prophets, so much zeal arises that it removes from him the attribute of lack of longing."
Minah-156:
I think that when the murid finds some quality of station or state in himself, he must know that quality is the sheikh's property, that it has been lent to him, and that the sheikh will take it back whenever he wishes. Even implicitly, he must not let the claim that it belongs to his own nafs enter the heart by his own wish, and he must strive to keep the causes of not owning that quality constantly in himself until he can guard them well. The Ghawth (k.s.) related from a sheikh in whose suhba he had been: "Mawlana Muhyiddin (k.s.) wrote a treatise. He had the name of an outward scholar written on this treatise as its author. After a while he erased the author's name from the treatise. When asked why he did this, he said: if someone gives another something from his property because of an attribute he thinks that person has, and then learns that this attribute is not in that person, then in jurisprudence it is permissible to take his property back."
Minah-157:
To state that the perfected khalifas of any tariqa may exercise discretion, in matters on which the pir of the tariqa did not speak, in order to bring the tariqa to perfection, and that this is not an innovation but permissible, Hazrat Ghawth (k.s.) said: "Shah Naqshband (k.s.) did not draw attention to eating little, but his khalifas commanded moderation in eating." For eating until completely full is an innovation. Our pirs, the Naqshbandi masters (k.s.), have transmitted to us through mutawatir report that they founded this exalted tariqa in order to protect it from innovations and even from concessions. So the way of the Naqshbandi is clear. The khalifas' view on eating is like the view of Shah Naqshband (k.s.). This matter is like the Shafi'i jurists acting on the ruling of Imam Shafi'i (may God be pleased with him): "When a hadith is sound, it is my school."
Minah-158:
One who reads the words of the people of God, or hears them directly from them, must not understand the meaning of what he hears in a purely outward and general way. The murid must not imitate the actions of the elders that seem outwardly contrary to the sharia and tariqa unless his sheikh commands it. But he must not deny them either, and must walk on the road whose limits the sheikh draws. Stating this, Hazrat Ghawth (k.s.) said: "Eating until full is an innovation because it did not exist in the first age (the Age of Bliss). Only to the perfected saints does it do no harm."
Alauddin Attar (k.s.) visited Shah Naqshband (k.s.) when he was ill, before his death. During this visit Shah Naqshband (k.s.) told him to eat from the table in the corner of the house. Alauddin Attar (k.s.) ate a little and wanted to rise. Shah Naqshband (k.s.), noticing that he was hungry, commanded him again and again to eat. After the third time he said: "O Alauddin, eat much, work much." Continuing, the Ghawth (k.s.) said: "Alauddin (k.s.) was one of the perfected."
Minah-159:
"The state and station prepared for a seeker according to his capacity may pass to others through his neglect." With these words they related: "In the time of Umar (may God be pleased with him), in a battle, one of the unbelievers wanted single combat with one of the Muslims. One of the Muslims came forward. But, scorning the unbeliever, he did not arm himself properly. Then, seeing the unbeliever's strength, he went back to complete his arms. Meanwhile another of the Muslims moved first and killed the unbeliever. These two Muslims could not agree about the spoils the unbeliever had with him, which belong to the one who kills him. The case was put to Umar (may God be pleased with him). He said: 'The spoils belonged to the first who came out, but he gave them up to the second.'"
Minah-160:
Pointing out the great benefits of entering this exalted tariqa at the hand of a perfected murshid, the Ghawth (k.s.) said: "The sheikhs cool the heart's eye of those who enter their discipleship toward love of the world. Giving up this love of the world does not mean abandoning the world. That is, it does not mean "do not earn wealth; be destitute." It is to prefer love of the Hereafter to love of the world, love of God (Exalted is He) to love of the world.
A man who has a house and a vineyard loves both. But though the repair of the house is made with the vineyard's income, he loves the house more. Preferring love of the Hereafter to love of the world is exactly like the example: preferring the goal to the means. This is the share of one who is guided through this discipleship. What a fine share it is, one that causes one to act cautiously and be guarded against many prohibitions."
The Ghawth (k.s.) pointed out some fruits of this share, saying: "Truly, the punishment of the grave is for the one whose love of the world exceeds his love of the Hereafter. There is no punishment in the grave for the one whose two loves are equal, or whose love of the Hereafter exceeds his love of the world."
Some sheikhs bring their murids to the complete abandonment of the world, which is the share of the gnostics. The gnostics' abandonment of the world differs according to their dispositions. Some abandon only love of the world and do not give up resorting to means. Some give up both love of the world and resorting to means. (Uways al-Qarani (k.s.) and others)
The Companions' (may God be pleased with them) abandonment of the world was not all of one kind." After saying this, he related incidents about it. He ended the incidents of the Companions (may God be pleased with them) with the story, mentioned in the hundred and sixtieth minah, of the two Companions (may God be pleased with them) who could not agree about the spoils.
At the end of the stories told, the Ghawth (k.s.) said: "The Companions' (may God be pleased with them) not abandoning the world is not like our not abandoning it. Rather, their outward inclination to the world was so that they might be followed, so that the legal rulings might be understood, and as an ease for those weak in faith. That is, it was so that the rulings might be known after them, not for their own nafs."
He also mentioned that when he asked his sheikh Sayyid Taha (k.s.) about the Companions' (may God be pleased with them) outward inclination to the world, he answered that this inclination was so that the rulings might be understood. It was generally the custom of Hazrat Ghawth (k.s.) in his high gatherings to mention stories and, at the end, to tell stories about the Companions (may God be pleased with them) which outwardly bring to mind something contrary to the greatness of the Companions (may God be pleased with them). Then he would explain those stories in such a beautiful way that those present were left in amazement. I have not met most of those beautiful explanations anywhere other than in his speech.
Minah-161:
In the eyes of one who knows his sheikh, all the states of the sheikh are miracles.
Minah-162:
In gatherings it is permissible to turn one's back on transgressors. But whomever you see, suppose him to be Khidr (peace be upon him) and do not turn your back on him.
Minah-163:
Stating that the sayr wa suluk is a difficult task, the Ghawth (k.s.) used to say that the nisba of this tariqa is majestic. In connection with this he said: "Mawlana Jalaluddin Rumi (k.s.) was honored even as a child with the station of minor sainthood. When he grew older and this great nisba came into his hands, he first counted what he had held as nothing compared with this nisba, and, regretting that he had not been acquainted with this nisba in the time of youth, which is suited to acquiring the perfection of the nisba, he used to say this couplet:
"There is a man who has a donkey but no packsaddle; until he finds the saddle, the wolf takes his donkey."
Minah-164:
One day in the exalted gathering, the possibility of arrival (wusul) without passing the greatest barzakh, that is, the Muhammadan Reality (the station of fana in the Messenger), was discussed.
A humble one said: "Some great saints have said that this is possible. Indeed, according to some, Rabi'a al-Adawiyya (k.s.) arrived in this way." Thereupon the Ghawth (k.s.) said: "Those who were honored in childhood with minor sainthood, like Mawlana Jalaluddin Rumi (k.s.), are of this kind. For when they were children they were not accountable."
I (Khalid-i Öleki) did not understand whether Hazrat Ghawth (k.s.) with these words indicated that arrival is possible without passing the barzakh of the Muhammadan Reality (peace be upon him), or whether he was specifying that in these cases, as with Mawlana (k.s.), arrival is possible without passing the barzakh of the sharia but not without passing the barzakh of the Muhammadan Reality (peace be upon him). My heart inclines to the second meaning.
Minah-165:
The Ghawth (k.s.) would command the salik to have lofty aspiration and forbid him from stopping at whatever appeared to the salik. For he said these states are an obstacle to the rise of those capable of progress, and he forbade inclining toward what appears.
Warning of the calamity of inclining toward what appears, he said: Inclining toward such things is like being content with the raisins and walnuts of the tariqa.
The salik's goal is to arrive at God (Exalted is He). A salik whose goal is arrival must not remain on the path, distracted by certain states and miracles that are like amusements. He must work to reach his goal as soon as possible. Capable persons who have not reached their goal have fallen behind solely because of their inclination to these states. One should not be content with what he finds on this path, and should not forget that the goal is to arrive at God (Exalted is He).
A humble one asked the Ghawth (k.s.): "The salik of the tariqa, while setting his eyes on the heights and wishing to rise to them, sees his nafs as utterly deficient, as worthy of nothing, and, since he is commanded to accept little as much in the tariqa, can the first of these be found together with the other two?"
The Ghawth (k.s.) answered: "Yes. Neither wanting the lower nor wanting the higher is a matter of capacity. Since this is from the bounty of God (Exalted is He), the two are equal. Indeed, refusing to be content with the lower level often means assuming that one has the capacity for it. And that is a great mistake," and then said: "The aim of seeking is not fruitless wishes but holding to the means together with seeking. The greatest means is to look for a perfected human being, and when you find him, to attach yourself to him and enter his service, until nothing remains in his presence from which you can benefit. After that you must leave him and look for one more perfect." The Ghawth (k.s.) recalled, on this subject, the famous story of Shah Naqshband (k.s.), who, when nothing remained to benefit from at his own sheikh's side, went to Khalil Ata (k.s.) and Qusam Sheikh (k.s.), and the story of Muhammad Shirin of Fez (k.s.), who left his sheikh and traveled west to find a more perfect one.
Then he said: "A perfected salik reaches increase through prayer and humble entreaty. What befits the salik is sometimes not to ask for a particular rank beyond his power, or one whose due he cannot fulfill, or the station of a certain person. Rather, as the Truth (Exalted is He) taught His Beloved (peace be upon him) with the verse فَتَعَالَى اللّٰهُ الْمَلِكُ الْحَقُّۚ وَلَا تَعْجَلْ بِالْقُرْاٰنِ مِنْ قَبْلِ اَنْ يُقْضٰٓى اِلَيْكَ وَحْيُهُۘ وَقُلْ رَبِّ زِدْن۪ي عِلْمًاExalted is Allah, the True King! Do not rush to recite ˹a revelation of˺ the Quran ˹O Prophet˺ before it is ˹properly˺ conveyed to you, and pray, “My Lord! Increase me in knowledge.” (Ta-Ha 20:114, Diyanet)[28], he hinted that one should ask for increase without restriction."
On this subject he related the story of David (peace be upon him), who was tested after he asked for the rank of the prophets of firm resolve. The Ghawth (k.s.) reported of himself: "One day I went to visit the grave of Uways al-Qarani (k.s.). At that time I asked the Truth for a nisba like his. Then I was afflicted with something that would lead me to death.
Just as the stations sought have no end, there is no end to seeking. It is possible that the delight taken in what one has and the longing for what one does not have coexist. But in worldly life these two do not come together in a perfect way. After death, progress continues."
After finishing the story of Uways al-Qarani (k.s.) asking nisba at his grave, the Ghawth (k.s.) said: "The Prophets (peace be upon them) truly find delight and joy in their graves with a relish and longing that we cannot reach."
Minah-166:
The Ghawth (k.s.) expressed what the courtesy of those who speak about the words of the sheikhs should be: "The courtesy of one who speaks about the words of the sheikhs is not to insist on the meaning he understood from the saying, nor to claim that other meanings cannot be understood, but to state that what he understood is one possibility among the meanings that can be understood."
My brother Mawlana Rasul (k.s.), though one of the men of virtue of his time and holding a large share in the spiritual way of this group, had written a gloss on a ghazal in the divan of Mawlana Jami (k.s.). In the gloss he wrote he had stated that the ghazal alludes to the event of Karbala. Then he cancelled the gloss he had written. He sought forgiveness and said, "From now on I will not speak about the words of the people of God."
Then the Ghawth (k.s.) said that those who explain the allusions of the saints must be as cautious as those who give fatwas, and that those who explain the allusions of the leaders of the tariqa must be even more cautious. Speaking of Mawlana Rasul's (k.s.) caution in giving fatwas, the Ghawth (k.s.) said: "He was so cautious that, even if it was his own student, as long as there was another person to give a fatwa he would not speak. In cases concerning himself he would ask his students for a fatwa."
To remove the idea that one should never speak about the words of the saints, the Ghawth (k.s.) hinted, citing his sheikh Sayyid Taha (k.s.): "The author of Tuhfa was one of the people of the heart. The scholars who do not understand the subtleties of the articles in the Tuhfa are permitted to speak about the Tuhfa, but they do not understand all of its subtleties." I think he warned that this humble one (Khalid-i Öleki) had misunderstood some allusions in the biographies of some sheikhs. May the Truth (Exalted is He) reward the Ghawth (k.s.) for his benefit to us. Seeking forgiveness from God (Exalted is He) for the fault that came from me, I have resolved from now on not to insist when explaining their words. I ask help from God (Exalted is He) and pray that He protect me in what I shall write from mistakes made unknowingly or through forgetfulness.
Minah-167:
Pointing out that the journey in the Naqshbandi tariqa is hard, that the true goal, the destination, is far, that the salik needs the sheikh, and that it is the sheikh who truly brings near and makes easy, the Ghawth (k.s.) said: "The ruins and the distances are behind this world, in the world of command. The sheikh, in reality, rains feyz from there upon this world in a time as short as the opening and closing of an eye."
Minah-168:
To indicate the necessity of cleansing the heart, the house of the secret, of everything other than God (masiwa) by being occupied with service and servanthood; that true arrival is not by the seeker's going to the sought but only by the sought's condescending to come to the seeker, which is a bounty; and that, after observing the courtesies mentioned as belief, asking with the tongue is of some benefit for arrival, he said:
"Some people with a close connection to me were busy building a mill for our Sheikh (k.s.). I was among them. So that my sheikh's exalted ear might hear, I said this couplet to someone.
"The portico of the view of our eyes is your threshold.
Be generous and come down, for the house is your own."
After I recited this couplet, Hazrat Sheikh (k.s.) came to us.
Minah-169:
One day Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) rode out to visit the graves to get some fresh air.
A humble one thought that Sultan Walad (k.s.) had gone on foot all the way from Damascus to Konya holding the stirrup of Shams-i Tabrizi's (k.s.) horse. He did not come with the Sheikh and was delayed for a while. I think it came to his heart: "If only there were a mount for me too." Then he set out to follow Hazrat Ghawth (k.s.). At the end of the journey he reached a stopping place and took up residence. In that town the exalted gathering was formed.
"The presence of one in the station of fana is like the presence of a person's breath. Just as a person's breath does not stop but continues even if he is heedless of it, so the presence of one in the station of fana continues even if he is heedless of presence."
Hazrat Ghawth (k.s.) said: "The aim of reading and studying the lives of the sheikhs is not to learn them but to act, even once, on what is stated there. Mawlana Jami (k.s.) once swept the floor of the Noble Kaaba with his blessed beard. He alluded to this also in his poem in his divan: 'I made my white hair a broom for your threshold.' Mawlana Haji Hakkari (k.s.), though a khalifa of Sayyid Taha (k.s.), one of the men of virtue of the time, one day swept his sheikh's floor with his white beard."
Minah-170:
The deniers are the wellhead of the gnostics' vineyard and spring. The benefit the sheikhs see through the deniers is greater than what they see from the murids.
Minah-171:
How fine the deniers are. For the person who is denied sees his nafs through their eyes, and his nafs falls from his own eyes.
Minah-172:
The Ghawth (k.s.) related that the sheikh of his sheikh Sayyid Taha (k.s.), Mawlana Khalid (k.s.), said: "What a fine sheikh Sayyid Abdullah (k.s.) is. He has no fault except that he has no deniers."
Minah-173:
Hazrat Ghawth (k.s.) would sometimes relate from himself, sometimes from his sheikh Sayyid Taha (k.s.): "It is possible for every denier to turn back from his denial. Except those who deny out of envy." Thereupon a humble one asked:
"Is envy not a sickness like the other spiritual diseases that the sheikhs try to remove?" He answered:
"Yes, it is. But envy is an obstacle to the submission that is a condition for the sheikhs' treatment."
Minah-174:
It was said to the Ghawth (k.s.): "So-and-so does not deny you. But he denies some of your murids." He said: "The denier of the branch is a denier at the root."
Minah-175:
To point to one kind of hidden denial, he said:
"The muezzin of our Sheikh was a denier. When the muezzin said, 'The Sheikh has grown lazy in the tariqa,' his denial was revealed." [28 Ta-Ha, verse 114]
[29 The aim of this minah is to indicate that true arrival comes about through the murshid bestowing and showing favor to the salik, together with the salik's observance of courtesy, without regard to the loftiness of the murshid's station. The salik must ask with his tongue for this favor that the murshid shows in condescension.]
[30 The Sayyid Abdullah (k.s.) named here is the uncle of Sayyid Taha (k.s.) and a khalifa of Mawlana Khalid al-Baghdadi (k.s.). He is the one whose name is read in the khatm. Since no silsila descended from Sayyid Abdullah (k.s.), Sayyid Taha (k.s.) included him in the silsila.]
Minah-176:
The outward scholars' denial of this group deprives them of benefiting from this group. It afflicts them with sorrow. It causes their abasement and poverty. Until the time God (Exalted is He) wills, this state passes to their offspring as well. As an example of this they related that a man regarded as the authority of his age in various outward sciences had written many books on the various branches of knowledge pursued in his day. The man was among the deniers of Sheikh Mawlana Khalid (k.s.). For this reason his books were not benefited from; more precisely, not even anyone was found to study them. Moreover, although he was one of the most handsome-faced men of his region, toward the end of his life a skin disease appeared on his face. What is more, this disease passed to his children after him. There was also a man among our relatives. The man was a denier of Sheikh Ismail Tillavi (k.s.), one of the great ones of that day. For this reason neither he nor, up to now, any of his descendants has been free of trouble and calamity. Yet his descendants today have reached the third or fourth generation.
Minah-177:
I was in Cizre. In my dream I saw one of the famous scholars of Shirvan of that time. That scholar was a denier of Sheikh Memduh-u Tillovi (k.s.). In my dream I saw that man's eyes go. A short time later news of his death came.
Minah-178:
Some events whose cause is not clear may seem outwardly contrary to the sharia. Pointing out that denying such events is also counted among true denials, the Ghawth (k.s.) related an incident that occurred in the time of his Sheikh Sayyid Taha (k.s.): "Sayyid Taha (k.s.) set out in the time of the war with the Russians to go to the front with a large group of volunteers. When he came near Van, it was revealed to him by unveiling that the outcome of the war would end in a peace agreement. After this spiritual state Sayyid Taha (k.s.) turned back. The war ended just as had been unveiled to him. But some people opposed his command to return and became his deniers.
Minah-179:
"The deniers of the people of God separate the true saints from those who are not. Through the deniers their perfections pass from potential to act, and the sincere become known." said the Ghawth (k.s.), who related this story: "In the time of Junayd al-Baghdadi (k.s.) deniers complained to the Caliph about a group of saints. At the end of the complaint these saints were sentenced to death. During the carrying out of their sentence, each of these sincere ones, preferring his companions to himself, stretched out his own neck to the executioner to be struck first. Had it not been for the deniers' denial and complaint, that perfection (preferring one's companion to one's own nafs) would not have appeared.
Minah-180:
The outward perfections of a denier are not to be considered. The excuse of weak murids who say they were delayed from the service of the people of God by arrogant deniers is not accepted. The longing of those who stay at home and do not come to visit, because of the praise and flattery of the arrogant and the intimidation and deceit of those who hold the weak back, is of no benefit to them. Rather, by this action they are like the person whom God (Exalted is He) describes in the verse اَفَرَاَيْتَ الَّذ۪ي تَوَلّٰىۙHave you seen the one who turned away ˹from Islam,˺ (An-Najm 53:33, Diyanet) وَاَعْطٰى قَل۪يلًا وَاَكْدٰىand ˹initially˺ paid a little ˹for his salvation˺, and then stopped? (An-Najm 53:34, Diyanet)[31]. There is a hint of the permissibility of backbiting the heads of the deniers out of compassion for the people. Those who visit the sheikhs, described as the Greater House of God, are of three kinds, like pilgrims.
The first are those who visit the sheikhs for God. These do not stop anywhere until they reach the station of fana.
The second are those who go for blessing and to take something outwardly. Even if their nafs does not entirely go, they still benefit from the sheikhs.
The third go to test the sheikhs, to see a miracle, to attain their worldly aims (fame, renown), and return deprived. The faults and defects they first hid come out. The reason for relating all this is as follows:
A humble one sent a messenger to the scholars of Bitlis with a letter that told them to hurry, regarding the opportunity as a prize, to come to the exalted door and that removed their doubts and objections about the exalted door. The messenger on his return related: "The letter affected very many of the scholars of Bitlis. They prepared to come. While matters stood so, they consulted the town's mufti about going to the Ghawth (k.s). He was the most vehement of the deniers; he had read the books of Sheikh al-Akbar Muhyiddin Ibn Arabi (k.s) without understanding them, was known for deviation and corrupt belief, and had just returned from the hajj. At a hint from this great denier, they gave up coming. A few days after this the Ghawth (k.s.) said in the exalted gathering: "When al-Walid ibn al-Mughira, having listened to the Glorious Quran and under its influence about to turn to Islam, asked Abu Jahl, Abu Jahl said to him, 'You are the sweet basil of Quraysh,' and deceived him by giving him certain whisperings. Consequently al-Walid ibn al-Mughira was deprived of eternal happiness because of Abu Jahl." After this story he recited this verse:
وَلَا تُطِعْ كُلَّ حَلَّافٍ مَه۪ينٍۙAnd do not obey the despicable, vain oath-taker, (Al-Qalam 68:10, Diyanet)[32]
Continuing the suhba, the Ghawth (k.s.) said: "When Abraham (peace be upon him) was commanded to call people to the hajj, it is related that first he called, then the Truth called, then the devil called. Whoever is reached by one of these three voices certainly goes to the hajj. One who goes to the hajj on hearing the call of Abraham (peace be upon him) performs his circumambulation, sees its benefit, and returns home. One who goes at the call of God (Exalted is He) does not return. He dies there. One who goes to the hajj at the call of the devil returns in a bad state and with a bad end. I heard this from a person I trust. The hajj is a touchstone that brings out the conscience of the heart and discloses hidden states." Then some of his companions incited the Ghawth (k.s.) toward the destruction of the one who had transgressed his bounds. At the end of the suhba, the Ghawth (k.s.), who explained the benefit of there being deniers, said: "For every Muhammad an Abu Jahl is needed." With these words the suhba ended. As the murids dispersed to their homes, letters of excuse came from a few of the scholars of that town. In this letter the scholars stated that their sincerity toward the masters had not been spoiled and that they had avoided denial. They wrote that only the mufti mentioned had prevented them from joining the humble ones of the exalted door.
The murids understood with certainty that the Ghawth's (k.s.) speech in this minah was to declare that the letter of excuse that came was not true. These words, like his other holy words, sprang from the light of perspicacity. I swear that all his speech was like that. Compared with his station, such instances of his perspicacity are but a drop from the sea, a speck from the earth; so we have strongly refrained from presuming to make him known through these minahs we have collected.
