Minah [31-60]

Minah-31:
He recommended rabita in all states. Only in suhba did he command heart-awareness (wuquf-i qalbi).
Minah-32:
Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) was asked: "Some shaykhs of our time make a claim that causes the truths to be hidden from the common people. They say that shaykhs may guide only the regions where they live. It is not permissible for them to leave their regions and guide in other regions."
He answered: "This is a groundless claim and a pure lie." He cited as evidence the struggle of Shaykh al-Islam Ahmad Namiqi Jami (k.s) with the Chishti shaykhs, which is related at length in the Nafahat. He also said that Shaykh Tahur (k.s) had said, "If I were not charged with dealing with politicians and preventing them from oppression, I would leave no murid to any shaykh in the world."
Minah-33:
Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) said: "One day I asked my shaykh Hazrat Sayyid Taha (k.s): As in the Nafahat, what is the reason that for some shaykhs the prayer 'sanctification' (taqdis) is recited and for others 'mercy'? He said:
- 'For one who is fully freed from his nafs, "May God sanctify his secret" (Qaddasa Allahu sirrahu) is said; for one who has something left of his nafs, "The mercy of God be upon him" (Rahmatullahi alayh) is said.'
After relating this answer of his shaykh, Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) said: Being fully freed from one's nafs is not a condition of guidance. Many for whom 'mercy' is recited have reached the station of guidance, walked on the right path and been of benefit to people."
Minah-34:
The established (mutamakkin) majdhub who is not cut off from the world of people while his lata'if are rising is more beneficial to the common people. The common people show more regard for these than for those who complete their sayr wa suluk and return. Since their relation with them is greater, recognizing them is easier.
Minah-35:
The son of Adam is forgetful in the beginning. For he has forgotten his covenant in the world of spirits and what passed over him. A person comes to have knowledge only after the lata'if reach their places in the world of command (alam-i amr).
Minah-36:
One of the murids asked Hazrat Ghawth (k.s):
- "While the murid is occupied with the virtuous self-examination (muhasaba) of the nafs, he sometimes becomes heedless of the rabita that causes annihilation (fana fi al-shaykh)."
He said:
- "Self-examination of the nafs is for those who see themselves as existing."
(Muhasaba benefits the person who sees himself as existing. For this reason the state of rabita is superior. If rabita brings one to annihilation, there is no need for muhasaba. In short, what is understood from this is that Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) preferred rabita.)
Minah-37:
It was asked of Hazrat Ghawth (k.s): "Are the lata'if separate from one another, as is well known? Or are they, as some shaykhs say, a single thing whose names change according to the station?"
In answer he said: "Each is a separate reality."
Minah-38:
When the lata'if begin to rise to the world of command, weeping most often arises in the murid. Yet the lata'if are going from this world, which counts as exile for them, to the world of command, which is their true homeland. An example of this is seen in the crying of a girl who is a bride as she goes to her husband's house, which is her real home.
Minah-39:
I, this poor one (Khalid-i Öleki (k.s)), was grieved that I was late in writing the Minah. On the third day after I began writing, while sitting in the suhba gathering before Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) with the same sorrow, he looked at me and recited this couplet: This Masnavi was delayed for a time. A delay was needed for blood to become milk.
Minah-40:
"A murid was teaching his shaykh the Fatiha, while his shaykh was completing his sayr wa suluk."
After explaining the difficulty of this, and that there can be no shaykhhood without observing the Sharia, Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) said: "His shaykhhood is not by present knowledge but by the earlier knowledge, the knowledge directly from God (ilm ladunni)." He reinforced it with this saying of some shaykhs: "I learned this knowledge twenty years before prophethood." He went on: "God (Exalted is He) knows the wisdom of this."
So that this matter might be better understood, he gave Shaykh Bereket and the like as examples, describing them as unlettered and excused by the Sharia.
Minah-41:
Among the diseases of the heart there is none more harmful than envy. The affliction of scholars is mostly because of it.
Minah-42:
"Sometimes one of lesser virtue recognizes the one of greater virtue, but the one of greater virtue cannot recognize the one of lesser virtue." Citing the well-known story of Khidr and the poor man, he said: "A poor Sufi recognized Khidr, but Khidr could not recognize the Sufi."
He explained the reason for this as follows: "When one of little virtue meets one of great virtue, the fayd he receives from him becomes the means of recognizing him."
The one of great virtue, since he receives nothing from the one of little virtue, does not recognize him. There are times when the opposite may occur as well. He cited as evidence "the story in the Nafahat of Shaykh Abdurrahman Tafvanji (k.s) not recognizing Shaykh Abd al-Qadir al-Jilani (k.s)."
Minah-43:
He said: "The condition of a person who performs the obligatory acts fully and guards himself from innovations is better than that of one who has various jadhbas and states but commits even a single innovation."
Then he related the story of the Bedouin who said in the presence of the Blessed Prophet (peace be upon him), "I shall neither add nor subtract," and about whom the Prophet (peace be upon him) bore witness, saying, "If he is truthful, he is saved."
Minah-44:
As for those whose khilafa is one of necessity (those given the khilafa on account of a need even though their station has not reached perfection), as long as they avoid innovations, people benefit from them. This is in fact the disposal of the spirits (arwah) of the shaykhs in that silsila. When these khalifas commit innovations, the shaykhs cut off their aspiration and disposal from them. Left alone with their nafs, their help to the people also comes to an end.
Minah-45:
In his exalted gatherings he said again about those whose khilafa is one of necessity: "As long as his shaykh is alive, people benefit from him. If his shaykh dies before he reaches perfection, his affair is dangerous and difficult."
Minah-46:
All innovations are darkness. There is absolutely no beauty in them. One who commits an innovation attributes the state he is in and the station he has reached to his innovation. Yet that state or station is from his deed that is not an innovation, which he is unaware of.
One reason for the superiority of the Naqshbandi Tariqa over other tariqas is that it has no innovation. The reason that no trace remains of some tariqas is the ill omen of innovations.
Minah-47:
In recent centuries, deeds that are Sunna, among innovations, have become like the light of a gem that sheds light from itself in the darkness of night. Because the time is a time of strangeness, today's righteous are given, for their few deeds, stations that the ancients could not attain with great struggles.
Minah-48:
Hazrat Ghawth (k.s), while conversing with his murids in a gathering, said: "That no benefit is seen today from other tariqas is because of the innovations in them. The time is a time of innovations. In this age, unless a tariqa is upright and free of innovations, it gives no benefit."
Minah-49:
In our age it has become very difficult to benefit from any tariqa other than the Naqshbandi.
Minah-50:
The saying of some people of unveiling (ahl al-kashf), "Among the tariqas the Naqshbandi tariqa, and among the schools the Hanafi school, will remain to the last," was discussed in the exalted gathering of Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) He said:
Hazrat Khwaja Ubaydullah Ahrar (k.s) said on this subject: "By the aspiration of the great ones the Naqshbandi Silsila will continue until the Day of Resurrection."
Minah-51:
Certain states come to one who completes his forty days in the retreat cell. He reaches certain stations. But the fayd that comes to the salik from suhba is superior. It makes him more perfect.
Minah-52:
The masters whose suhba is worth attending have set a sign. He would recite this famous quatrain of Hazrat Azizan (k.s):
With whomever you sat, your heart was not gathered.
The toil of water and clay (the elements) did not leave you.
If you do not shun his suhba,
The spirits of the Azizan will never absolve you (of their due).
Minah-53:
To those present in his exalted gatherings he would say: "Measure your inward state in our gathering and outside it. If you see no difference between them, do not come to me."
Minah-54:
The training (sayr wa suluk) whose fruit becomes the murid's own possession is only the training that comes through suhba and service to his shaykh. What comes otherwise, through means such as a glance, is fleeting. This state rarely remains as a possession. What is rare is as though it did not exist.
Minah-55:
People benefit only from one who has passed the station of annihilation in God (fana fillah). They cannot benefit from the people of istighfar who are still in that station. Yet the benefit meant here is the benefit of training.
Otherwise the saint in every station exercises aspiration in matters such as repelling calamities and bringing blessing. Indeed, this is found in murids too.
Minah-56:
The salik in the state of absorption (istighraq) does not wish to exchange the spiritual state he is in for that of one whose lata'if have risen, reached annihilation in God and returned. Yet the one whose lata'if have reached annihilation in God and returned is more perfect.
Minah-57:
One who, after reaching annihilation, returns to subsistence (baqa), returns again to absorption (the station of fana fillah) at the time of the prayer and at the moment of death.
(The person in the station of absorption is unaware of the people's affairs and is occupied with all his feelings with the spiritual effusions (fuyuzat) that come to him. Sometimes he even passes beyond his own nafs. The one who has returned, just as God (Exalted is He) is present in his heart, is not absent from the people either. This returned person, being heedless of everything besides God during the agony of death and in the prayer, enters absorption again.)
Minah-58:
From some great ones in the station of annihilation in God, the benefit of training is seen.
Muhyiddin Ibn Arabi (k.s) was beneficial while in this station.
Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) said that no regard should be given to sayings such as "I saw my Lord in the form of a horse," which some utter in the state of intoxication (sukr).
Minah-59:
In the exalted gatherings of Hazrat Ghawth (k.s), there was a conversation about sincerity (ikhlas). I (Khalid-i Öleki (k.s)) asked about sincerity. He recited a couplet of Mevlana Ahmed of Cizre (k.s):
I swear by the Quran and the verses,
If the pir of the tavern (the tariqa)
were to say, prostrate to Lat,
the murids would follow him.
When I said, "Is sincerity this much?" he said, "Is this not enough?"
Then Ghawth (k.s) turned to this poor one (Khalid-i Öleki (k.s)): "What do you say about sincerity?" I said: "In my view, sincerity, as the hadith qudsi indicates, is for the murid to believe with certainty that all of his shaykh's words, deeds, movements and stillnesses are only by the pleasure and command of God (Exalted is He)." Ghawth (k.s) approved this answer of mine and said, "This is true sincerity. Anything other than this is, like the quatrain above, the speech of the people of intoxication."
Minah-60:
"Outward compassion and formal favor delay the murid's suluk. But the murids are not content without them. We do not know what to do either."
My shaykh, Sayyid Taha (k.s), would not speak to me and would not look at me. Sometimes he would not even come to the khatm and tawajjuh at which I was present.
