Can Damlaları

If Fatih Had Lived Ten More Years, All of Us…

We spoke with Prof. Dr. Heath W. Lowry, a faculty member at Bahçeşehir University and a member of the advisory board of Derin Tarih magazine, known for his work on Sultan Mehmed the Conqueror (Fatih), about the background of the conquest of Istanbul, Fatih Sultan Mehmed's intellectual identity, and the achievements behind his being regarded as a pioneer of city planners.

Could you tell us about Fatih's career as sultan?

It is truly very interesting… In the dynasty, apart from him, there are two people who ascended the throne twice: the first is his father Murad II, the other is Mustafa I. Of course his father Murad II gave him the throne himself, but Fatih was only 12 years old then. He was not alone; around him were statesmen who would guide him, but it seems to me that from the beginning Fatih trusted the Janissaries more than them.

After he ascended the throne, some dangers appear, don't they?

Yes. He is very young and inexperienced; enemies, both from within and from outside, are stirring. They call Murad II to the head of the army, and he comes. The Battle of Varna takes place. A young boy could not possibly stop a whole Crusader army anyway…

Now, there is a frequently told incident of a letter. Fatih supposedly wrote to his father, "If you are the sultan, come and take your throne. If I am the sultan, I command you: take the throne"…

This anecdote appears in many places, but I have not come across such a letter so far.

When he ascended the throne again in 1451, it seems he had only one thing in mind.

To conquer Istanbul! Of course, since the time of the Prophet Muhammed, the goal among the Umayyads, the Abbasids and the Seljuks had been to conquer Istanbul. And of course once he took it, there would be no such thing as Byzantium left. I even describe it like this: there is a huge Ottoman sea, and Byzantium is like a tiny island in the middle of this sea. Fatih set his mind on it and did this.

He was not alone, of course.

Of course. There is always a perception like this: "In Ottoman history the sultans did everything." No, there is no such thing; these matters are not that easy in fact. Around Fatih there are many interesting people. For example, there is a raider (akıncı) like Evrenosoğlu Ali Bey. He joins the siege with about 10,000 horsemen. Later he is given a place on the shore of the Golden Horn: the area around today's Alibeyköy, that is…

What role did Akşemseddin play in the conquest?

According to the sources, Akşemseddin joins the siege with 3,000 dervishes and plays a very critical role during the conquest. On the one hand he gives spiritual strength to Fatih and the army, and on the other there is an interesting letter he wrote during the siege. That is very important in my view. Akşemseddin writes the letter at a time when things were not going very brilliantly, and says: "Do you think these men are fighting for God's good pleasure? They are fighting for booty!" After that, the soldiers were promised that if the city was taken it would be plundered for three days. Of course, on the third day Fatih put a stop to the plunder. And during the plunder he had only one condition: buildings were never to be damaged!

Plunder is for conquered lands, isn't it?

Yes. If you take a place by your sword, you have the right to plunder there. But there is also this situation: for example, let us look at the Ottoman conquest of Bursa. There was no cannon technology in that period. They placed the city under siege. This lasted a full 11 years, and in the end the tekfurs in Bursa had to surrender the city.

Likewise İznik can be given as an example. In İznik the siege lasts 9 years. The city would again surrender on its own. We see this a great deal in the Balkans in the 14th century. Many cities in the Balkans were not taken by military force; they generally surrendered.

Why?

Because if the Ottomans were handed the city, they did not touch the people. They did not harm their houses of worship and their homes. But if the people of the city resisted and the city was taken by the sword, things changed. In Istanbul they offer the Byzantines the same terms, but they do not accept. A large part of the Ottoman soldiers consist of raiders. They are not salaried and fight for booty. That is, whatever they take from the booty will be their pay. As Akşemseddin also emphasized, the army needed something to motivate it.

Fatih attaches great importance to the city, doesn't he?

From the beginning he attached great importance to this city; we see this clearly. Before the siege began he had Rumeli Hisarı built. When the city fell, they learned many lessons from this siege. They understood that the huge walled cities left from Rome and Byzantium hundreds of years earlier had already become unable to defend themselves. Because now there was cannon technology. And as soon as he took the city, he built a curtain wall at one corner of the walls and had the Yedikule Fortress built for lookout. When his father Murad II took Thessaloniki in 1431, he had done the same, building a curtain wall in front of the new walls at the very top and adding towers. By coincidence, that one too is called Yedikule Fortress.

What do you think about the overland hauling of the ships?

By God, to speak frankly, I have never fully believed it. Now we say that these were carried from Beşiktaş over the top of the hill. Well, where did the ships come from? First they would need to be built. If a shipyard had been built in the Golden Horn and they had come from inside the Golden Horn, it would have made much more sense, in my opinion. But I think it is a very difficult job. Even with today's technology it is not an easy thing at all…

After the conquest of Istanbul was achieved, what were the echoes of the conquest?

It truly made a great echo in the West. For the Ottomans it was not that important. Because they had already reached the Adriatic. As I said, the conquest has a symbolic, that is, spiritual value. No Muslim ruler had been able to conquer this city. Therefore the conquest of Istanbul raised Fatih to a prestigious position in the Islamic world.

The Ottomans had gone as far as the Adriatic and were expanding. They would take Istanbul sooner or later, wouldn't they?

For about 100 years, those we call Byzantine emperors had in any case been keeping their places in return for money. For example, Emperor Manuel II makes such an agreement with Yıldırım (Bayezid I)… Namely, you will pay this much a year, and on campaigns you will join the Ottoman army with this many soldiers. Manuel takes part in an Eastern Anatolian campaign in 1391, and there he writes to his teacher very pitiful letters to the effect of "What a state we have fallen into, we are fighting against our own people."

Of course, when the city fell, some high-ranking Byzantines joined Fatih. At the head of these is the diplomat and historian Kritovoulos. Also the philosopher Amirutzes, one of the advisers of the Greek emperor of Trebizond, is one of them. There is actually a very interesting link here.

What is that link?

Fatih's Grand Vizier Mahmud Pasha and Amirutzes are cousins. In 1461 Mahmud Pasha goes to Trebizond by sea with an army. Fatih comes by land. Until Fatih arrives, negotiations take place between the "two cousins" and the city is taken over.

From what Kritovoulos wrote we see clearly that when Fatih was not on campaign, he and Amirutzes talked philosophy for hours in his palace. Fine, the end of Byzantium had come, that is true. But that does not mean all the notables of the city went to Italy or here and there. Some of these people became Ottomans; we see this very clearly.

Let me give a much nicer example. Constantine XI, who was on the throne at the time of the conquest, was someone who had no children at all even though he married twice. But his elder brother Theodore had three sons. Fatih takes all three into the palace, and these children grow up in the palace. One of them is Has Murad Pasha, an important statesman. The other is Mesih Pasha, who later becomes a son-in-law of Bayezid II.

Look, these were not merely Byzantines; had the city not fallen, one of these children could have become emperor. But Fatih is afraid of nothing. He takes those from the upper class of the enemy into his own service.

Well, what happens to the third child?

For many years this was a question mark in my own mind too. I discovered it recently and published it as an article. In a survey register (tahrir defteri) dated 1478, in a place north of Serres, there is a wealthy holder of a zeamet. The man's name is written as Palaiologos, and beside it a note: "brother of Mesih Pasha." He alone remained Christian, but he too serves the Ottomans.

What does this indicate?

That is what Ottomanness is. We see this very clearly in Fatih. In my view he is afraid of nothing, except one thing: plague. The plague came to the city at least five times. There is an epidemic lasting about five months, and nearly 600 people die a day. When Fatih received news of this while on campaign, he did not return until the plague was over. He kept sending men to obtain information.

IF FATIH HAD LIVED TEN MORE YEARS, ALL OF US WOULD HAVE BECOME MUSLIM

After the conquest Fatih goes on 25 more campaigns, doesn't he?

It seems to me that Fatih was going to take every known place in the world of that time. That is, he had this in mind. In that respect he is not very different from Alexander the Great. Alexander the Great looked to the East, but Fatih's eye was always on the West. Probably if he had remained on the throne ten more years, all of us as far as England would have become Muslim (laughs).

Let me give you a very interesting piece of information: in 1480 he leaves 300 Janissaries at Otranto in southern Italy. Of course when he died, those poor 300 Janissaries stayed there. Because they were professional soldiers, they joined the armies of some princes there. I have not seen it, but my German friends told me. In Bavaria there are supposedly one or two settlements named "Janissary." Probably these are names left from those Janissaries.

Coming to the matter of the maps in the palace library, I think Fatih was carrying this project in his mind. What do you say?

In the 1980s, more than 120 Greek manuscripts were found in a room in Topkapı Palace. This event created great excitement especially among Byzantinists in the West. Of course they thought the library of the last Byzantine emperor had been found, and so on. The very talented British scholar Julian Raby worked on these books and sensed that something was odd. The bindings of the books were leather, but the leather had come apart (paper is put inside the leather bindings of that time), and he saw that the papers had siyakat script, that is, a script used by the Ottomans. Then he paid attention to the watermarks of the papers. He saw that these papers were Venetian-made. All of them have watermarks dating to around 1457-75. So these belonged not to the Byzantines but to the Ottomans.

What was among those books?

Very interesting… There are two or three İskendernames, and these works tell the life of Alexander the Great and how he conquered the world. Fatih too was dreaming those dreams. The philosophers who entered the palace also wanted to give him these ideas. They would say to him, "You are the Alexander the Great of our time, you will conquer the world." Fatih knew Greek and, most probably, Serbian.

A true Renaissance man, in other words. Curious not only about military technologies but about everything. His relationship with the famous Italian painter Bellini is very well known anyway…

Is it true that Fatih took the lands of the foundations (vakıf) from their hands?

Now, raider families like the Evrenosoğulları and the Mihaloğulları did not merely go about with swords in hand standing at the head of the raiders. These are the people who conquered the Balkans.

Evliya Çelebi very carefully says: "The Balkans were conquered by the hand of Evrenos." In the survey registers of the early period we see that timars are given to them. We should not interpret the events of the 14th and 15th centuries with the system of the 16th century. In the early periods a large part of the places these families conquered remained to them as private property. These families establish foundations and have immense incomes; they are unbelievably rich. In my opinion Fatih's aim was to destroy the power of these families. He thought: "Only if I can get hold of their lands will I be able to establish the necessary dominion over them."

Bayezid II then gives these back. Why?

That is a very good question! (Laughs) Yes, when Bayezid II gave them back, these foundation properties continued until 1923. But I cannot give the answer to why he gave them back. Because to this day no one has done a proper study on Bayezid II. In fact he is such a great ruler… We always hold wrong opinions. To perceive the Bayezid era as a stagnant period between the reigns of Fatih and Yavuz is very wrong.

What do you say about the matter of Fatih's death? Was he poisoned in your opinion?

There are various rumors. They tried to poison Fatih many times. But it is a fact that he had gout. For one thing, it is a disease that causes terrible pain. The very last thing one should do with gout is ride a horse. And he went on campaign every year. Also, when we examine the kitchen registers of his period, we see he ate very high amounts of caviar and lobster. These too are things that trigger gout. Whether he died of gout or of poison is still not clear…

What would you like to say about the matter of Ulubatlı Hasan, who is said to have planted the flag on the walls first?

There was surely someone who planted the flag. Popular memory produces things and tells them. Moreover, popular memory is very weak.

In the early 1970s, while working on Trabzon, I would go back and forth there whenever I had the chance. One day I went to a place 3 kilometers south of the city. There was a ruined remnant, and I began to research it. In Greek sources it is called the Tower of Maria, in Turkish sources the Tower of Fatih.

Do you know what that remnant actually was? In 1905, Abdülhamid II had an arsenal built in Trabzon. In 1911 that arsenal exploded. These walls are the remains of that arsenal. That is, people's memory is very weak.

I can give hundreds of examples like this. When something pleases the people, whether it is true or false is not very important.

Source: Derin Tarih