Blessed Talks of Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s)
What is related below, I heard from Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s), and he in turn heard from Hazrat Ghawth al-A'zam Arvasi (k.s). Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) said:
When Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) was in Gayda, he said:
-A talk about the greatness of the twelve imams lifts darkness from food.
-A murid may tell the states he has reached in the tariqa to a brother who will not be jealous of him. There is no harm in it. Indeed my father
– may God gladden his spirit – said:
-In the days when Molla Ahmed-i Dumlî and I entered the tariqa together, we used to tell each other the states we encountered.
When Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) learned of the matter, he did not forbid this act of ours. He even said:
The people of Ispahart are unruly. For this reason they are fond of wealth and women. If these people benefited from the fayd and blessing of Sufism, they would give up their fondness for wealth and women and cling to this path with all their effort.
Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) said:
When a tahlil that only those taught and instructed by Naqshbandi Sheikhs know is recited and its reward donated, the punishment of the grave is lifted from the dead.
Indeed Hazrat Arvasi (k.s) used to order that this tahlil be recited and gifted to the spirits of the dead whom he supposed to be suffering punishment. Hazrat Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) said:
-My rabita advanced so far that it came before my eyes even when I was in the toilet. I felt great shame at this.
I presented the matter to Hazrat Arvasi (k.s). Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) said to me:
-This is a spiritual state. Do not feel shame at it. Moreover, when Abu Bakr (r.a.) complained to the Prophet (peace be upon him) of the same situation, our Prophet said likewise.
Hazrat Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) said:
–Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) explained the meaning of the adhan to me as follows. When the adhan is heard, one should reflect as follows.
ALLAHU AKBAR: It means, “The Almighty Lord of the Worlds is so great that He has no need of worship.”
ASHHADU AN LA ILAHA ILLALLAH: It means there is no one worthy of worship besides Him.
ASHHADU ANNA MUHAMMADAN RASULULLAH: “What the Prophets say is true; the sharia brought by our Prophet Muhammad Mustafa (peace be upon him) is true.
Accordingly, prayer is an obligation never to be abandoned, it is a fard. The servant earns reward for the prayers he performs. If he abandons it, there is painful punishment and great deprivation. Two meanings emerge here.
HAYYA ALA'S-SALAH: “Come to prayer so that you may attain a great good.” This word points to the first meaning.
HAYYA ALA'L-FALAH: “Come to fulfill this important obligation so that you may be saved from painful punishment.”
This word points to the second meaning. A person who listens to the adhan should say at this point:
(La hawla wa la quwwata illa billah) that is (I have no power to obey, I have no power to be saved from punishment, it is only with the help of God (Exalted is He)).
Saying this is recommended. Here the listener may show slackness, since nothing remains to the servant.
The muezzin's saying again “Allahu Akbar” and “La ilaha illallah” removes the slackness in the listener.
ALLAHU AKBAR: It means “God (Exalted is He) is so great that your worship is not worthy of Him. Therefore all the benefit is yours.”
By saying these, the servant's slackness goes.
LA ILAHA ILLALLAH: It means “The only one deserving of worship is God (Exalted is He), and He is also the one who saves from punishment.”
This good word removes despair, he said.
What Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) relates in this section concerns some of the miraculous states of Hazrat Ghawth (k.s).
Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) said: “One of the Sufis of Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) had lost some sheep. The murid asked Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) for spiritual aid (himma) so that his sheep would be found.
When I arrived in his presence, he was eating watermelon with his son Muhammed. Handing me the watermelon rinds he said, “Whoever eats these rinds is the one who must find the place of the sheep.” Hearing this, I did not want to eat the rinds.
But when Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) said to me, “Eat,” I ate.
Before long the sheep were found. Upon this he said: “This is the result of sincerity (ikhlas).”
Another event is this: “At one time one of the notables of that region was in prison. When Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) learned of this event, he said:
-If he had sincerity, he would be freed from prison. In this case I informed that person:
–“Repent, give up heedlessness” I said. I also sent the socks of Hazrat Ghawth (k.s). When the word reached this person who was unjustly in prison, he repented at once.
Upon this, through the spiritual aid of Hazrat Ghawth (k.s), he was released the next day.
Another event showing the miracle of Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) is this.
Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) said:
“Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) had gone on the Hajj by way of miracle. He would gather with his abdal twice every Friday. They would be busy with service, and he would take their burdens and illnesses upon himself.
Indeed, many times when we (Sayda-i Tagi and the other abdal) went to distant places at his command, our feet would strike stones. When we returned, I would see blood flowing from his foot as well.
After Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) died, I served another Ghawth for about ten days.
I saw that between him and our Ghawth Sayyid Sibghatullah Arvasi (k.s) there was a difference as great as mountains.
So I ceased to be his abdal. Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) said: “They threw me into prison unjustly in a certain town.
Then I saw that Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) was coming to my aid riding a white horse. Immediately afterward I was delivered through his exalted spiritual aid.”
According to the blessed statements of Hazrat Ghawth (k.s), in the Naqshbandi Tariqa they had attained absolute annihilation (fana) and the station of haqq al-yaqin.
Just as no one from other tariqas could reach this rank, so among the members of this Exalted Naqshbandi Tariqa as well, no one except
1)Shah-i Naqshband,
2)Sheikh Abdulkhaliq Ghujdawani,
3)Khwaja Alaaddin Attar,
4)Imam-i Rabbani has attained these degrees.
One of the murids of the Ghawth (k.s) fell ill. His illness approached the point of death. He asked the Ghawth (k.s) for spiritual aid and help (istimdad).
The Ghawth (k.s) sent me to his aid. When I went, I saw that he had recovered and been healed. Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) said:
– The devil that had beset me has submitted to me. He had told us this to inform us of a truth. Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) said:
-Years ago, just after I had become affiliated, I wanted to sit next to a molla in the tawajjuh. But Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) prevented it and made me sit in another place.
I understood the wisdom of this years later. Namely, coldness arose between that molla and me because of his objections.
” Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) said:
-One day Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) said as follows. It was said to me: Those who see you will not see the face of hell. I told this to one of the brothers, and he was very frightened and said:
-I wonder who can see him?
– After that I went to the Ghawth (k.s) and conveyed the worry my brother had felt. The Ghawth (k.s) said.
-What is meant by seeing is sincere attachment.
–When I asked the Ghawth (k.s), who told you this news, he said, “My Lord said.”
“I tested the unveilings and miracles of Hazrat Ghawth (k.s). Each time it turned out as he said.
But once he said that so-and-so would come in fifteen days. That man came after the time he had announced. It differed by only five days.”
Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) said: There was a woman who had served Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) for a time and had a son. One day this youth fell ill.
The youth's mother came to Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) for spiritual aid. Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) said: The sick one will not recover. The woman insisted again. Although the Ghawth (k.s) said his appointed time had come and he would not recover, the sick one's mother insisted to such a degree that she wept and pleaded.
Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) could not bear it and went to where the sick one was. We went too. Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) began to turn pale and wither. It turned out that he had exchanged his spirit with the sick one's spirit, giving his own spirit in place of the sick one's spirit.
For Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) had said: The Angel of Death has come. He will not return without taking a spirit. Before long a Sufi named Salih, who was carrying firewood, arrived.
When Sufi Salih understood that Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) had chosen to give his own spirit in place of the child's, he at once threw the firewood down from his back
-Do you not see the state the Ghawth (k.s) is in? O my Ghawth, may my spirit be sacrificed to you, he said, and ran to the Ghawth (k.s).
He gave his spirit in exchange for the Ghawth (k.s). The Ghawth (k.s) and the sick child recovered. For Salih had given his spirit in exchange.
He related the following stories from the Ghawth (k.s) in the year 1296, in encouragement of the sharia.
–Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) asked me about the states of the scholars and said: The aim is the realization of uprightness in conformity with the sharia.
To this I said to him, “since the tariqa is attachment to the sharia, no one is more attached to the sharia than Molla Muhammad Emin.”
Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) replied in a wrathful manner, “he washes his face four times when he performs ablution.”
–When Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) was in Gayda and asked me about the states of Molla Abdullah and Molla Hüseyin, I spoke of Molla Abdullah and praised him. When I said of Molla Hüseyin that he had turned to the sharia, he said, “Good, the aim is the realization of uprightness.”
-Again one day in Gayda, Molla Abdurrahman Melakendi said with sorrow that, at the pool where he had gone to perform ablution, he saw in the water the reflection of a woman cleaning with her hands and face uncovered.
He asked me to relay this event to the Ghawth (k.s). When I relayed it to Hazrat Ghawth (k.s), Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) objected strongly and, wrathful, said: Do you not know that this situation is for the common people, you are a scholar, it is objectionable for you.
Do not let your eyes wander to what you have no need to look at. A molla had spoken this way and that about women coming and going to the exalted tekke.
I had been the cause of this. Upon this I said: We are obliged to be together with women, yet we avoid those women, and I swear by divorce that we do not see their faces.
When Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) heard these words of mine, he said that it was not good to answer according to circumstance in the Emir's house, and said: Answering by state is not acceptable.
The acceptable answer is the one in conformity with the sharia. Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) had gone to a village to give guidance. He went into the mosque and sat down.
The villagers came to visit him. But those who came entered the mosque with their left foot. Only one Sufi entered with his right foot.
Upon this Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) said, “How far you are from being murids! The only murid is this Sufi who enters the mosque with his right foot,” and smiling, gave a talk to that Sufi.
Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) valued Bajuri's narration highly. Once one of the Sufis brought a book from Istanbul. Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) gave me this book and ordered me to examine it.
While reading the book I saw this passage: “One who dies concealing his feelings from his beloved and shrinking even from looking is like a martyr.”
I showed these words to Hazrat Ghawth (k.s); the blessed one looked and read. After a while Molla Muhammad came to me in excitement and said:
Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) said that in the book he gave you it is written that “the condition of love is concealment and chastity.”
One night I was sitting with Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) in the Emir's house. At one point he went out. After a while Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) came in majestically, sat down and said to me:
-Call my son Hamza. The Ghawth (k.s) was very angry with Hamza. I made a plea, but he became angry with me too and did not accept.
He also rejected his son and son-in-law on this matter. Later his servant Molla Salih came. He said, My Master:
“Our spirits are about to leave us out of fear; you are of the Muhammadan temperament. Compassion and mercy are the attributes of your exalted person.”
What is this state of yours, what has made you wrathful?” he said. Upon this Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) said: Do not misunderstand me.
For I have established that my son Hamza was talking with a woman on the roof. The matter was immediately investigated and witnesses were brought.
When it was testified that the woman Hamza was talking with was his own aunt, the heart of Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) found calm and his wrath passed.
He had us repent and said, “Do nothing without my permission.” His son Sheikh Bahauddin asked, How shall we consult you when you are not with us?
In answer to this question Hazrat Ghawth (k.s),
said, “Refer to the sharia, do what is in accord with the sharia.” One day Hazrat Mawlana Sayyid Taha (k.s) sent a letter to Hazrat Ghawth (k.s).
In the letter he said:
–If the murid has complete sincerity and love toward his sheikh, and attachment through following, the murid need have no state at all.
If there is a deficiency in these qualities, there is fear, “God forbid,” that the state in him will lead to istidraj. Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) attached this letter to the section titled Alaaddin Attar of the Nafahat al-Uns.
Afterwards for some time they made this letter the opening topic of the talk. Again one day Molla Abdulgaffar-i Kali came to the tekke.
I had had a discussion with him. When I later presented to Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) the discussion that had passed between us, he said to me the following:
–Go and tell him this: come and read the sharia here. You read only the outward side of the sharia; now read its spiritual side. The sharia as you understand it forbids the eye to look at the forbidden, while the sharia as I read it forbids the heart to look as well”
On another occasion he ordered me to say: ”You read the outward part of the sharia, but ask me about its essence”
Again one day, after relaying Molla Yusuf's saying “One who acts on the sharia, who applies and puts into practice the sharia, is a saint (wali),” Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) said: Molla Yusuf neglected one point, for it is not possible to grasp the essence of the sharia without passing through the talk and training of a Sheikh who has reached the station of annihilation (fana).
Again one day I put this question to Hazrat Ghawth (k.s):
-Why are the legal opinions (ijtihad) of the outward scholars needed? Is it not enough to refer to the sheikh who has reached the station of annihilation in every matter?
My purpose in asking this question was this. (My attachment to him had reached such a degree that I believed he would never say any word contrary to the sharia.) He answered my question as follows.
-The reason for this need is this: Even if the scholar himself is a transgressor or a sinner, his word and ijtihad rest on knowledge.
But the sheikh's word rests on state. Since that is so, the scholar's word is better and better founded, he said.
Again one day, when Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) was in Kulat, he ordered us to ask forgiveness (istighfar). I had asked: “Is the istighfar you have ordered the Naqshbandi istighfar or the sharia istighfar?” He said to me in astonishment:
-What difference is there between the two? I said to him: In my opinion the Naqshbandi istighfar is the servant's presenting his need of God, taking refuge in Him, and imploring and pleading with his heart; while the outward istighfar consists of saying “astaghfirullah.”
Upon this he said: The essential aim is supplication, istighfar and taking refuge. But the sharia has found it fitting that these heartfelt and state-based feelings be expressed openly in words on the tongue. Saying these words with the tongue is absolutely necessary.
Excellent for one who can unite the word with the meaning; otherwise saying it with words is also sufficient.
A recommendation about dhikr came from Sayyid Salih, brother of Hazrat Mawlana Sayyid Taha (k.s). Upon this Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) asked us to say, before the prayers, before the iqama is recited, ten times “Subhanallah,” ten times “Alhamdulillah,” ten times “La ilaha illallah,” ten times “Allahu Akbar,” and ten times “Astaghfirullah.”
When this became known among the people, the said dhikr became widespread and came to be practiced everywhere.
When this dhikr reached Sheikh Khalid Jazari, a khalifa of Sheikh Mawlana Khalid (k.s), that blessed one wrote a letter to Hazrat Ghawth (k.s).
The letter came to us. In his letter he said: “I could not understand the order of Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) to say the mentioned dhikrs ten times each. Yet there is no sharia proof on this matter.”
When the letter of this great Naqshbandi sheikh, a man of precision, discussion and learning, arrived, the Ghawth (k.s) gave no new order.
That is, he said neither that it should be recited nor that it should not. He waited for the arrival of Khalid-i Shirvani. This waiting was out of caution.
Indeed, when Khalid-i Shirvani came, he was asked about this matter. This person said that there was no sharia proof whatever on this matter.
Upon this Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) withdrew the earlier order he had given and forbade us this dhikr. For the unanimous fatwa of two scholars was sufficient.
In addition, there was a custom in the villages from long ago. On the nights before the blessed month of Ramadan and the Feast of Sacrifice, while Surah ar-Rahman was being recited, takbir was said with one voice.
When we asked Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) his view on this matter, he said to us: “I can say nothing on this matter. But I cannot adopt it until a sharia proof is found.”
From this statement we understood that we needed to look for a sharia proof on this matter. We immediately sent word to the mufti of Siirt. I put the fatwa that came in my pocket to give to Hazrat Ghawth (k.s).
But before I gave him the fatwa, Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) asked Sheikh Khalid the same question.
When Sheikh Khalid said this custom has no place in the sharia, Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) forbade us to follow this custom until the matter became clear.
Meanwhile I had lost the fatwa that came from the mufti of Siirt. Thus we had no recourse but to wait for these matters to be clarified. The sheikh of the Ghawth (k.s), Hazrat Sayyid Taha (k.s), had ordered this dhikr mentioned in a book of manners (adab) to be performed.
But in that book there was no statement as to whether the ten tahlils said after the morning and evening prayers and before the tasbihat are sunna.
For this reason Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) himself did not perform this tahlil dhikr. One day when he went to the mosque to perform the evening prayer, he saw after the prayer that the congregation did not perform the said dhikr; when he asked the reason, they said to him:
“The imam told us that your exalted self had ordered us not to do it.” Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) became very wrathful at this answer and said: May God's wrath be upon whoever lies in my name!
How could I forbid a dhikr that has a place in the sharia? As for my not performing it, it is because my Sheikh gave me not this dhikr but another one like it.
I cannot disregard this command of my Sheikh. For I firmly believe that there is wisdom and benefit in his command. In most of the books written by our elders attached to the Naqshbandi tariqa, loud dhikr (jahri) is forbidden.
This adab had spread so far that we had come to avoid all loud dhikr and recitations. Upon this one day Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) said: Not all loud dhikr and recitations are forbidden.
Rather, what is forbidden is reciting aloud those dhikrs and recitations whose being recited aloud or silently does not rest on a sharia proof. Those whose being recited aloud rests on a sharia proof may be recited aloud.
For example the takbirs said on feast days, the talqin given to the dead and the like.”
I (Sayda-i Tagi (k.s)) was sitting one night with my family. A righteous woman came in. My wife also went out, the door was open, and she stayed outside for a moment. Then she came back. The next day when I came to the exalted assembly of Hazrat Ghawth (k.s), it turned out that he had learned of that situation at home; wrathful, he took the staff in his hand and rebuked me, saying “I will beat you with this staff.” He showed me mercy.
With wrath he warned, “You must know that you possess the nisba.” There is much evidence that Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) acted in conformity with the sharia.
It is beyond counting. For example, one such proof is that even among the majdhubs found at his door the rulings of the sharia were realized.
Indeed once, a woman Sufi kissed my hand while the sleeves of my robe were over my hand, such that she had no contact at all with my hand.
A mad woman who saw this said, “What you are doing is contrary to the sharia.” Women who wished to be blessed by Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) would kiss his hem.
Sheikh Abdullah, in the marginal commentary on the book written by Sheikh Zakariya al-Ansari, in the section titled “Enjoining the Good,” says:
-The one who commands a ruling of the sharia need not necessarily be just.
For example, a person addicted to drink can forbid sitting with a non-mahram.
According to Imam Ghazali too, a man who commits zina with a woman can order her to hide her face.