Tawajjuh, Hatme and Suhba

Hazrat Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) said as follows: Teach the murids to sit properly in reverse tawarruk during tawajjuh.
The noble Sadat regarded it as commendable that those who recite in the hatmes be few. In the hatme circle it is good for the listeners to be many and the reciters few. For they remain longer in the state of rabita and so gain more benefit and fayd.
Hazrat Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) said: The essence of suhba is silence. And turning to me, he asked me to explain the saying: "If a person is silent, how can love appear?"
When I answered, "Our master knows best," he replied, "God and His Messenger know best," and then said:
Know that love is an attribute of the spirit. But its obstacles are the desires of the self. Accordingly, when you concentrate your heart on one point, love comes into being there. It is understood from this explanation that;
A person who wishes love to appear in his heart must concentrate his heart on one point and restrain the desires of his self.
If a murid takes part in suhba and love does not appear in his heart, the one responsible for this is not the sheikh but the murid.
For it is the murid's duty to gather his heart and to keep his self from its lusts.
Hazrat Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) said: Teach the murids the etiquette of being in suhba.
The etiquette of being in suhba is that the murid never neglect to keep his own heart turned toward the heart of his murshid. Only then can he benefit from suhba.
For the divine manifestation (tajalli-i ilahi) descends during suhba and is distributed among the Sufis. It enters the heart of the one who is not heedless.
It leaves the heedless one and goes to the one who is awake. The tajalli is like smoke or vapor. Only those with sincerity, surrender and love can perceive it.
Teach the murids also the etiquette of being present at tawajjuh. During tawajjuh the murid must contemplate his sheikh as being like Hazrat Jesus.
The sick come to Hazrat Jesus, and he treats them with potent medicines. The murid himself is spiritually sick and has no other remedy; he is present in the gathering where the healing takes place.
It is hoped that the scent of the potent medicines will reach his nose, and that he will take a breath and be healed. On another occasion, when Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) was asked about the etiquette of being present at tawajjuh, he described it in the above manner, relating from Sheikh Khalid Uleki (k.s), the khalifa of Ghawth (k.s).
Also teach the murids the etiquette of the hatme.
There is no harm in explaining the description of the hatme in a loud voice to those who are murids.
After love, sincerity, surrender and adherence to the Shariah, which are the basic pillars of the tariqa, there is nothing of greater worth than etiquette and respect toward the master.
Teach those who newly enter the tariqa without fail to perform the ritual bath (ghusl) with the intention of repentance. For one who has not performed ghusl is not considered to have entered the tariqa.
Hazrat Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) said: The prudent murid sits in the suhba of his sheikh concealing the faults and defects of his self, and in return revealing his attributes of perfection. The master's final words were:
Thus the murid is always striving to appear pleasing to the master. As I understood, what is meant by the attributes of perfection are the lights that shine on the murid's face.
These lights are the lights of seeking forgiveness and repentance. For in another suhba he said:
I do not see in the state of such-and-such a woman the trace of the darkness of the great sins she committed. For when she came to the suhba with the intention of repentance, the light that covers her darkness appeared in her.
Hazrat Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) said: Both in verbal suhba and in the suhba of silence, the murid must await the fayd that will come from his sheikh with the wuquf of the heart (wuquf-i qalbi). Continuing his words, he also pointed out the difference between verbal suhba and the suhba of silence:
-In verbal suhba both the ear and the heart take a share. Accordingly one must both listen attentively and take one's heart into wuquf. The suhba of silence is not so.
The benefit of the wuquf of the heart is that it makes one feel the arrival of benefit and nisba through the outward senses of eye and nose.
Wuquf is of two kinds: absolute and restricted. Restricted wuquf is the one described above; the other is absolute wuquf. Absolute wuquf was formerly widespread among the Naqshbandis. Later, when rabita became prominent, this kind of wuquf was abandoned.
Indeed Hazrat Ala al-Din-i Attar (k.s) used to teach his murids absolute wuquf. The master ended his words thus.
– As one descends in the tariqa, purity increases and nearness to benefit grows.
Hazrat Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) said: In such suhbas the wuquf of the heart is easy. What is hard is to be able to maintain the wuquf of the heart when words are spoken that outwardly seem foreign to the suhba.
If the murid is absolutely annihilated (fani) in his sheikh, he understands the lesson and indication in the word spoken. For he must know his sheikh to be absolutely annihilated. The murid must believe that there is a lesson in every word and deed of his sheikh, otherwise his sincerity is weak.
If the master's words are far from indications, he is not absolutely annihilated. For the words of God are not far from indication. It is recommended that the murid be cleansed of indication. For this reason the murid must investigate every word of his sheikh and understand what he means.
If the murid does not understand the sheikh's words, he accepts it as a likeness, a simile. Just as there are mutashabih verses in the Noble Quran that must be believed, so in the words of the master there are mutashabih words that call for sincerity.
He does not ask for an explanation of these words. For to ask is contrary to etiquette. It is not permissible. For if he asks his sheikh to explain the meaning of something and then, having learned it, does not act upon it, he is harmed. For obscure words become a command when explained.
Only, if the murid comprehends the words himself without having his sheikh explain them, it is not required that he act on those words; it is good if he does. Hazrat Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) said:
If a person who has sincerity and love in him comes among the people of this tariqa and sits in the hatme in accordance with its etiquette, it is good that he not be removed from the circle.
But great ones of ours such as Mawlana Khalid, Sayyid Taha and Sayyid Sibghatullah al-Arwasi (k.s) strictly forbade those who are not in this tariqa to take part in the hatme. I am of the view of not forbidding such persons. But our master did not state a definite ruling on this matter.
"It would be good to put the etiquette of the tariqa into writing and record it.
Those who have not performed the ritual bath (ghusl), that is, who have not done the etiquettes required and taught for entering the tariqa, who have not performed ghusl with the intention of repentance, can by no means enter tawajjuh."
"The murid cannot benefit from the tawajjuh of another sheikh. For how can he turn his heart to anyone other than his own sheikh? Since he cannot turn it, he cannot benefit from him."
Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) in one of his suhbas mentioned these etiquettes:
1)When tawajjuh is being performed, after the sheikh has come in, no one speaks.
The sheikh too may speak only as much as necessary. In the tawajjuhs of Ghawth-i Azam the murids would form rabita in this way:
Rays like the rays of the sun come out of the sheikh, take hold of the murid and enter the heart beneath the left breast. In this heart there are animal feelings (the animal heart).
There is also another heart; this is a light that covers every part of the body. Its head is within the heart, which consists of a piece of flesh.
This light can be perceived only through the himma (spiritual aid) and mediation of a perfect murshid.
2) Before the wirds; to seek forgiveness three, twenty-one or twenty-five times, and also to recite the Fatiha, is of the etiquette of our tariqa.
The benefit of the Fatiha and the seeking of forgiveness is this:
By pleading to the great ones and asking for help, one should abandon one's own being (one's own selfhood).
3)Rabita is performed during the wird.
4)If one stops while performing the wirds, for rest or for some other purpose, before starting the wird again one seeks forgiveness and repents again.
After the murid finishes his wirds, he also seeks forgiveness and repents.
5)Repenting and seeking forgiveness after the obligatory prayers is of the etiquette of our tariqa.
Hazrat Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) gave this suhba one day: The absolutely annihilated sheikh is one who, having stripped himself of his own will, has entered the will of God Almighty. That is, he speaks only what God Almighty commands and makes only that his aim.
Hazrat Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) one day fell from his horse and fainted, and then gave this suhba:
The absolutely annihilated sheikh, however difficult his situation, must give every moment he lives its due. For this state is their attribute. Did I give its due to the moment I fell from the horse? I cannot remember that moment. The due of that moment is this: Praise, thanks, seeking forgiveness…
The great murshids take charge of their own tariqa. Nevertheless, they do not like their exalted thresholds to remain empty. The himma of some of them is on their own thresholds, and of others on the heirs of the exalted tariqa.
Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) said that his master Ghawth (k.s) related to him this memory concerning the deniers:
"One night I stayed as a guest in the house of the qadi of Zakho. The qadi was a denier. On another day I slept in a church. Believe me, the harm I suffered in this qadi's house was greater than in the church."
Hazrat Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) says; one day Sayyid Taha (k.s) said:
"The heart of a murid who eats a single morsel of a denier's food does not make dhikr for forty days." Again my master Ghawth-i Azam (k.s) considered being with deniers more dangerous than being with unbelievers.
Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) says; the denier is harmful for the murid but beneficial for the sheikh. One day we were guests together with Ghawth (k.s) in a town, food was offered and Ghawth (k.s) said,
"You (Abdurrahman Tagi) and Sheikh Bahauddin will not eat this food." We did not eat, but the blessed one himself ate. The reason was this:
By eating the food of their own deniers, the sheikhs deny their own existence. This denial is of great benefit to the sheikhs. The case of the murid is different.
That is; the murid, by eating the denier's food, is considered to deny his murshid. This does very great harm to the murid.
Hazrat Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) said in one of his suhbas:
-The state of the great ones is very different. That is; you look at the things that are very important to us and they attach no importance to them. And to the things that are unimportant to us they attach great importance.
The wrath and objection of the great ones are of two kinds:
One is for the purpose of warning, the other for the purpose of destruction. Their wrath for the purpose of warning is this: it is for the purpose of striking those who have strayed from the road, warning them and preventing them from going to destruction.
The second is: the wrath that does not abate, from the moment they wish the destruction of those they address, until their faith is gone. May God protect us. Look at some of the deniers of Ghawth-i Azam (k.s), they suffer no harm at all from the world. Yet the signs of unbelief were seen in them.
Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s), in one of his suhbas open to the public, said as follows:
-Once through unveiling I saw something in my hand. I looked and it was a scorpion; I threw it to the ground at once.
I opened my eyes and looked; an animal like a bear was playing with it. I looked again carefully. That animal was a pig.
When the blessed one gave this suhba, I (Ibrahim Chokreshi) (k.s) said to him: Master, what does this animal signify?
He answered: That pig is a human being put into the form of a pig. We spoke with the master about a person who had been very sincere earlier and later became a denier.
I said to the master: Master, the one in the form of a pig must be the one who was sincere earlier and later became a denier. The master (k.s) said:
The murshids are agreed that a person who was a sincere murid and then became an apostate enters the form of an animal.
When these events were told to me, I was going to make that man repent and have him perform ghusl. For if a man who has entered the form of an animal repents while in the world, he returns to his former state. After he dies, it is impossible for him to return to his former state.
Because he has gone without faith. In the time of Ghawth, I think, there were deniers who went without faith.
Denial arises from ignorance; and also from knowledge. Denial from ignorance is less harmful than that from knowledge. The most harmful denial is that born of envy.
Look at Ahmad Jami (k.s); eleven persons denied him. Ahmad Jami is the cause of the death of ten of those eleven. When Ahmad Jami (k.s) was asked why ten died and one survived, he said:
"This person's denial was due to ignorance. The masters (sadat) did nothing against this person, neither in his religion nor in his worldly life."
Sayda-i Tagi (k.s) said: Look, those who gave the fatwa for the death of Hallaj-i Mansur were forty persons.
These were scholars. Thirty-nine were held responsible for Hallaj's death.
Their independent judgment was the cause of Hallaj's death. But they did not interpret. Therefore they were harmed. That one person was not harmed because his knowledge was not at the level to interpret that word.
I (Ibrahim Chokreshi) asked Sayda (k.s) what the scorpion seen in the vision was. He said:
It is the very same person as the pig. Because he showed his enmity openly he was seen in that form.
Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) says.
Khalid Shahruzi (k.s) said: For the murid, the condition that arises from lack of sincerity and love, and the illness that arises from innovations, is very bad. Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s), saying that these words are very true, continued as follows:
The murshid cures his murid of every kind of illness. Except the illnesses arising from lack of sincerity and love and from innovations. For these illnesses change the murid's rectitude.
The murid departs from the Straight Path; but these can be cured. One who commits adultery knows adultery is a great sin. Then he feels remorse. Those who commit the other two do not know that they have sinned, and they feel no remorse.
So the essence of the remedy is remorse, seeing the fault of one's self. It depends on pleading to the master and taking refuge in him.
The sign of those who have lost the human form and entered the form of an animal is that they are not affected by sermons and counsel and continue in the sins they commit.
I (Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s)), knowing that denial endangers faith, did not deny the person who claimed to be a saint.
I only took a stand against those who denied my sheikh.
I would not deny, but I would take a stand.
Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) says: The murid who says "why?" and "for what?" to his sheikh will not prosper.
The gates of fayd are closed upon the murid who objects to his sheikh.
The murid cannot examine his sheikh and object to him.
I asked Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) a question like this: "Rabi'a al-Adawiyya had gone out in attire that was perhaps unbecoming.
One of her devotees said: This attire will cause you to be blamed. Is this word counted as an objection to Rabi'a?
Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) said: No, it is not counted. Because this is advice.
The Noble Companions (may God be pleased with them) too from time to time advised the Prophet (peace be upon him); only, when it concerns the master it is better not to advise.
Advice is not like objection, its harm is less. Hazrat Ghawth had three kinds of suhba:
In one suhba no worldly person could speak; in the second, matters of a third kind, concerning the needs of the people, were discussed.
He used to forbid us from this kind of suhba. And there was one suhba assembly that was only for himself, in which he spoke in a humorous style.
A sincere murid meets all the deeds of his murshid with surrender. It is related in some books as follows.
In the time of Hazrat Abdulkhaliq Ghujdawani (k.s) there was a Ghawth who commanded the rain-laden clouds. This Ghawth asked the clouds to rain upon a town in great need. But the rain did not fall. The clouds carried the rain to a rugged region. Much rain fell on that region.
After this event the Ghawth said: "O my Lord, why did You not rain upon the place in need but rained elsewhere?" At this word, his rank of Ghawth was taken from him by God Almighty.
He fell to the ground unconscious, in the form of a dog. One of the murids who noticed this state appealed to Hazrat Abdulkhaliq Ghujdawani (k.s). He prayed, and his prayer was accepted. Then the former station and rank were restored to this Ghawth by God (Exalted is He).
Hazrat Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) said: "Those who are qualified can, by sitting in their suhba, determine which of the sheikhs is true.
The seeker must read the books that set out the etiquette of the tariqa. Then if the suhba of the one in whose suhba he sits accords with the etiquette, that person is a sheikh.
When doubt-inspiring thoughts (khawatir) appeared in the heart of a mulla about taking part in suhba and tawajjuh and meeting and speaking with the Sufis, Hazrat Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) said in his private suhba:
-If the doubt and thoughts that appear in your heart are causing a decline in sincerity, there are two remedies. The first; is to cast such feelings and thoughts out of the heart, the second; is to find another perfect murshid and attach oneself to him.
Only this point you must know: that those who leave the sheikhs without finishing the needed practice and becoming possessors of perfection have not reached their goal.
Sheikh Nureddin Birivgi (k.s) is an exception to this. Because his sheikh rejected him, he attached himself to another tariqa and was not harmed.
For Mawlana Khalid al-Baghdadi (k.s), who was the sheikh of his sheikh, did not cut his nisba from him because the fault was not his. One day I asked Hazrat Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s):
"Master, does the denier give up his denial after he dies?" He answered: "Yes, he can give it up. Moreover, some deniers have responsibilities toward others. For example, this is so for those who became deniers out of ignorance.
The nephew (his brother's son) of Ghawth (k.s) was my teacher. While alive he was a denier of the blessed Ghawth (k.s). After his death he asked me to be an intercessor with Ghawth (k.s).
I conveyed his wish to Ghawth (k.s). The blessed Ghawth (k.s) did not answer for nearly a year. Then one day he said to me: "He repented and gave up his denial. For this he was forgiven."
If a person denies one sheikh and accepts some other sheikhs; in this case, if the sheikh he denies is the Qutb al-Azam, he can receive nisba from nowhere.
If the sheikh he denies is not the Qutb, he can receive nisba from the other sheikhs he accepts.
Sheikh Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) says: One day I went to visit Sheikh Khalid Uleki (k.s), one of the khalifas of Ghawth (k.s). When the time of prayer came, he did not put the madrasa student beside him forward as imam. I could not understand this behavior of his.
I thought he might have acted so for these reasons. Either this student is a denier of Ghawth (k.s), or Sheikh Khalid stepped forward as imam in order to be rid of the sense of selfhood. For in former times leading the prayer was to be avoided because it fostered a sense of selfhood.
In the present time, however, leading the prayer is a sign of moving away from the sense of selfhood. Because the one who is imam knows that among the congregation there is surely someone of a higher degree than himself.
Sheikh Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) pointing out that the master is never to be objected to, that the murshid's words and acts that are not understood must be accepted as general (mujmal) and mutashabih and referred to him, and that the thresholds of the great ones are free of any wrongdoing, said as follows:
–Ghawth-i Hizani (k.s) had two murids called Alican and Aziz. Alican, withdrawing from everything, was a sincere man of love who had wholly surrendered to Ghawth (k.s). Because of this state he reached exalted stations.
Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) said of him: – Not even for as long as it takes a bird to dip its beak into water and lift it out is Alican's heart heedless of God. Then a day came when certain misgivings arose in Alican's heart.
He came to have objections to some of those attached to the door of Ghawth (k.s), because of acts that in his view were contrary to the Shariah. I seek refuge in God (Exalted is He) from such a thought. But after a short while Alican repented and set his belief right.
To atone for the doubt he had been seized by, he went to other towns. After some time he returned to the dergah of Ghawth (k.s).
As for Mulla Aziz, he chose to make himself agreeable to people by appearing to follow the way of the Shariah.
For this reason he would object to Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) because of his acts that seemed outwardly contrary to the Shariah.
He used to try to dissuade Ghawth (k.s) from that behavior. Because of this conduct he could never tear down his feelings of "ego (ana)" and show loyalty and surrender.
Hazrat Ghawth (k.s) said as follows concerning these two murids: Each time fayd comes for Aziz, my spiritual presence (ruhaniyya) gives it to Alican, and Alican, by virtue of his love, also receives the fayd that comes to his friend.
