Can Damlaları

The Nisab of the Sacrifice

Slaughtering a sacrifice is obligatory (wajib) for persons who have the following qualities:

1. Being a Muslim

2. Being free, not a slave

3. Being a resident, not a traveler

4. Being wealthy, by which is meant a wealth sufficient to give the sadaqa al-fitr. That is, those who own 20 mithqals (82 g) of gold or 200 dirhams (640 g) of silver are obliged to slaughter a sacrifice. It is not a condition that a year pass over this nisab.

The sacrifices slaughtered by those who do not own the nisab in this way, and by pilgrims who are not residents of Mecca, are counted as voluntary (tatawwu') and supererogatory sacrifices. The sacrifices slaughtered in hajj al-tamattu' and hajj al-qiran, however, are obligatory. They are distinct from the udhiya sacrifice. Being male is not a condition for the sacrifice to be obligatory. For a free woman who owns the amount of the nisab, too, it is obligatory to slaughter a sacrifice with her own money. (Sunan Abu Dawud, Turkish translation and commentary 10/453-454)

2. The sacrifice is obligatory for every sane, adult, Muslim, free, resident man and woman wealthy enough to slaughter a sacrifice. The measure of wealth is that, according to the Hanafi school, it is obligatory to slaughter a sacrifice for every Muslim who owns, beyond his basic needs, 20 mithqals, that is, 82 g of gold, or money or trade goods of this amount. According to the Shafi'is, Malikis and Hanbalis, however, the sacrifice is a confirmed sunnah. Indeed, according to the Hanbalis, a person who has the ability to pay, if he can obtain the sacrifice money even by borrowing, is counted as able to slaughter a sacrifice. (Al-Fiqh 'ala'l-Madhahib al-Arba'a)

2. The exegete Elmalılı Hamdi Yazır says: "Slaughtering a sacrifice is an act of worship that expresses a greater sacrifice than giving zakat and sadaqa al-fitr. Therefore, although ability is a condition in it, it does not require ability as great as zakat does (a high degree of financial ability)." (Hak Dini Kur'an Dili, 9/1697)

3. The view of our school's imam, Imam al-A'zam, that the ruling on slaughtering a sacrifice is obligatory, is of course also based on these two firm foundations of the legal proofs (the Book and the Sunnah).

Nevertheless, the mujtahids of the Shafi'i, Maliki and Hanbali schools ruled that slaughtering a sacrifice is a sunnah. The view of those who hold that slaughtering a sacrifice is a sunnah rests on this noble hadith: "When the ten days of the month of Dhu'l-Hijja begin and one of you wishes to slaughter a sacrifice, let him not take anything from the hair or nails of his sacrifice." (Muslim, Adahi, hadith no. 1977)

4. Those who say that slaughtering a sacrifice is a sunnah hold that the word "man arada (if he wishes)" in the noble hadith expresses choice (the ability to act as one wishes, freedom). Imam al-Marghinani (may God have mercy on him), however, says that this is not arbitrariness and choice but the opposite of inadvertence, and so it can be understood in the sense of "if he intends to slaughter a sacrifice."
(Al-Hidaya, 4/113)

5. Imam Muhammad (may God have mercy on him), one of the mujtahids of the Hanafi school, although he reached the ijtihad that slaughtering a sacrifice is a sunnah, says, "it is a sunnah that one has no license to abandon."

The majority too declare the opinion, "It is a confirmed sunnah by way of sufficiency (kifaya)." Likewise Imam Malik (may God have mercy on him) says, "The sacrifice is not obligatory but a sunnah. But I would not look kindly on one who is able and does not slaughter." (Muwatta', 2/384)

Basic and essential needs

1- The house in which a person lives

2- The household goods he uses

3- The clothes he wears

4- His mount

5- A slave for service

6- The weapon he uses

7- The books of a person of knowledge

8- The tools of a craftsman

9- A year's food.

Books held by one who is not a person of knowledge are not a basic need. Clothes beyond three sets, household goods beyond what is necessary, surplus land and houses are included in the nisab. If a person has a field and has secured from that field the year's maintenance for himself and his family, the sacrifice is obligatory upon him. If what comes out of the field is not sufficient for a year's maintenance, he is counted as poor. (Radd al-Muhtar – Durr al-Mukhtar vol. 6, p. 312 – Bahr al-Ra'iq vol. 8, p. 198 – Büyük İslam İlmihali)

If a poor person or a traveler slaughters a sacrifice and then becomes wealthy and a resident before the third day of the festival is over, his earlier sacrifice is sufficient. According to the soundest view, he need not slaughter again. (Radd al-Muhtar vol. 6, p. 316)

It is recommended (mustahab) for a person upon whom the sacrifice is obligatory to slaughter a sacrifice also for his children who have not reached maturity. It is not obligatory like the sadaqa al-fitr. (Jawhara – Radd al-Muhtar vol. 6, p. 241)

It is obligatory not only for the head of the family but for everyone in the family who is wealthy to slaughter the sacrifice. Some people say, "I always slaughtered; this year I will slaughter for my wife." This is wrong. If it is obligatory for the wife, both must slaughter every year. If it is not obligatory, he must slaughter himself. Otherwise he remains in debt.

According to Imam al-A'zam Abu Hanifa and Imam Abu Yusuf, reason and maturity are not conditions for the sacrifice to be obligatory. If an immature child has property enough for the sacrifice to be obligatory, it is obligatory for his guardian to slaughter a sacrifice from his property. (Durar vol. 1, p. 267 – Durr al-Mukhtar – Radd al-Muhtar vol. 6, p. 316 – Hidaya vol. 4, p. 71 – Jawhara vol. 2, p. 241 – Bahr al-Ra'iq vol. 8, p. 198)

According to Imam Muhammad, children and the insane are not obliged to slaughter a sacrifice, nor are their guardians obliged to slaughter on their behalf. For according to Imam Muhammad, reason and maturity are not a condition.

Accordingly, by the ruling of the Hanafi school, according to Imam al-A'zam and Imam Abu Yusuf, the father or guardian of a wealthy child or insane person must slaughter a sacrifice from their property. (Büyük İslam İlmihali, p. 390)