The Difference Between Seeking and Ascent [1]

A) If ascent depends on seeking, it requires passing from one station to another, from one state to another. Progress (taraqqi), on the other hand, does not depend on seeking, so the Sufi gains breadth within the station in which he already is.
B) The second difference is this: although there is no seeking for the dead, there is progress. The progress of the dead is this:
For example, for a person who passes away while in the state of sayr (journeying), the increase of the delight he had in that state and the widening of his portion in it is that person's progress.
The one who dies in the state of unity (wahda) likewise rises as his journeying in this state increases and his share widens.
The dead do not rise by passing from the station they are in to another station.
The light of faith of a person of faith who has died without attaining any perfections increases. The light of faith is a very great blessing. It may even be said that it wipes out sins. For this reason you see that the murshids' aversion to someone who has just died passes after the date of death has gone by. For those whose date of death has grown old are rising.
One reason for the ascent of those who have passed away is that the great ones remove the heart diseases in them.
Consider Molla Ziyauddin, whom we knew; he was a denier. When he died he suffered great distress. I saw him in my dream. He told me to ask for help on his behalf from the Ghawth (k.s).
I presented the matter to the Ghawth (k.s). The Ghawth (k.s) did not accept my request for a year. After a year the Ghawth (k.s) called me and said: “The heart disease into which the Hoja had fallen has been removed. The Hoja has been forgiven.”
Among the deniers of the Ghawth (k.s) there was a man named Molla Abdulghani. When this person died the Ghawth (k.s) said:
“He is being tormented, clothed in a shirt of fiery tar.” Some time passed after this talk. The son of the Ghawth (k.s), Shaykh Jalaluddin, spoke against Molla Abdulghani.
Then the Ghawth (k.s) said in a gentle tone:
-Be silent, he was our brother. I (Seyda-i Tagi (k.s)) understood that Molla Abdulghani's heart disease has been removed. He too has been forgiven.
During this talk the following question was asked: My Master, how is it that the great ones show no mercy to their own relatives when they pass away?
Seyda (k.s) said: The Ghawth's (k.s) not showing mercy to his brother was not because of his denial of his person.
It was because his denial extended as far as Sayyid Taha (k.s). See, denying the branch requires denying the root too.
The Ghawth (k.s) said so. One day I said to Seyda (k.s): My Master, such-and-such a person does not aim his accusations at our center. He only denies one of our companions…
Seyda (k.s) answered these words as follows: I am astonished. For how can you say this person does not deny the shaykh.
“Calling bad what the shaykh calls good” is to deny the shaykh.
Because this speech means that the shaykh is speaking wrongly.
May the Almighty make all of us among those who love Him. May He protect us from being enemies of those He loves.
Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) says:
“Perfections are two. One is the perfection of sainthood (walaya), the other is the perfection of prophethood (nubuwwa). A murid must first obtain the perfection of sainthood.
To obtain the perfection of sainthood a murid must practice the rabita of the master much.
That is: the murid must imagine his master upon his own heart (within it). If a murid practices rabita in this manner for eighty days, it is hoped that he will reach his absolute goal.
According to some masters, if rabita is established in this manner, it is hoped that the murid will reach the aim in one hundred and sixty days. The correct view is that it is reached in eighty days.
To obtain this blessing the murid must strengthen his rabita to his shaykh so much that he has no awareness of any creature. Until he forgets even the road he himself walks.
He should not even see those who fall into ecstasy (jadhba) and perform sama'. See, the Ghawth (k.s) would at times test us to see the state of our rabita.
One day I had bound my heart wholly to the murshid and entered rabita. At that moment the Ghawth (k.s) said to a Sufi: “Play an instrument, make the bear dance.” I (Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s)) did not see what that brother of ours did. When I left that gathering I said to Shaykh Bahauddin:
“I heard that the Master told a brother of ours to make the bear dance. Why did that brother not make it dance?” Shaykh Bahauddin said: “He made it dance. The play ended. After that we dispersed.”
The Ghawth (k.s) rebuked us in two gatherings.
The first: one day we were sitting in a gathering where the rules of etiquette were not observed. Because etiquette was not kept, we left that gathering and assembled in another.
Into the congregation where we had just sat down, a majdhub came. He began to speak loudly in the presence of the Ghawth (k.s). While all these things were repeating, we too failed to turn our hearts wholly toward our murshid and establish rabita.
At that moment the Ghawth (k.s) said to us in wrath: “I tested you in both gatherings. I saw that you did not establish your rabita and did not picture your shaykh in your hearts. Not one of you is worth a penny.”
The murid must first obtain the perfection of sainthood, and only then set about acquiring the perfection of prophethood.”
Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) said: “The state of the tariqas in our day is clear. The people of our time are also clear. See, in this age of ours the people of these lands are very ignorant.
They make light of the commands and rulings of religion. They commit great sins and make light of small sins.
In this age, those who put aside the affection and love of the world and turn to the Almighty are saints, even if they have no state at all.
The mercy of the Almighty toward the people of this time is greater than His mercy toward the people of past times.
This is so although the people of this age commit more sins.
This being the case, the people of our time, after repenting and becoming murids, progress greatly in a short time with little work and obtain stations.
These stations they obtain could not be obtained in the past by long austerity and labor.
In our day, a person may attain a state even a day after repenting.
Indeed there are such people. Shah Naqshband (k.s) says: “The foundations of this tariqa are very firm. Even those who commit great sins, even those who commit and perpetrate great crimes, may enter this path.”
Seyda (k.s) said: “Do not look at the austerities that Mawlana Khalid (k.s) practiced. Those austerities were temporary and for certain murids. He did not give every murid the same task.”
In the past, people would seek a murshid even though they were devoted to God's commands and rulings and did righteous deeds. Because they believed in the difficulty of the matter without a murshid, and that the door of the perfect murshid was a door of gain.
The people of our time are very different. They are in a very strange state. They come to the door of the shaykhs sunk in the swamp of sin.
The journeying of those of our time is a kind of flight. That of the ancients was not like this. That is why austerities have lessened in this age compared with the earlier ages.
Mawlana Khalid (k.s) was a man of knowledge and action. He was also a man of contemplative witnessing (mushahada) and a khalifa of the Qadiri order.
Adorned with these blessings, he attached himself to Shah Dehlawi. The murids of our time, by contrast, attach themselves to the tariqa having committed great sins.
Those of our time go to the murshids not because of what they have but, on the contrary, because of what they lack (knowledge and action).
One day Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) wished to build a mosque on a plot of land jointly owned by a dhimmi and several persons, but some deniers regarded this as oppression and opposed it.
Seyda (k.s) then asked us for a fatwa. We gave the fatwa: “The sum the owners of the plot ask must be paid.” Seyda bought the plot and began the construction of the mosque.
Afterward they gave the following talk: “We gathered the spiritual wealth in our hands from the rubbish heap of the deniers. For this reason we heed the words of the deniers; they are our mirror.
Because a person sees his faults better through the eyes of the deniers. Just as we repent of the matters that Islam counts as faults, we repent also of the matters for which the deniers accuse us.
Ibrahim Chokreshi (k.s) says: one day, I behaved faultily in prolonging the mosque matter. Then Seyda said to me: “When a person wishes to reach God, he must be neither too far ahead nor too far behind.”
He must follow the middle way. Let him also keep his heart narrow, so that nothing but the Almighty remains in that heart, that unity may be realized.
In matters of the Sharia, however, the work is not done by halves. One must strive to do all things fully, otherwise a person cannot advance. A person should think broadly.
He should not create difficulty for the community, he should examine every matter fully and remove doubts. “Also, a benefit of the deniers is that they remind a person of his errors and sins and lead him to repent.”
One day the Shaykh had a task, and it was asked that I do that service.
A reluctance arose in me. I said: It would be better for him if another Sufi did this service, the task weighs on me. Upon this the Shaykh said:
-When a person is constrained, doing a task is harder for him than not doing it. But it is easy for him to propose to another a task that is hard for himself. Yet a person does not know that the good of that task is not for another but for himself.
On the contrary, when a task is pleasant, a person finds doing it easier than not doing it. But it comes easily to him to advise a friend, and not himself, not to do that task. Yet he does not know that the harm of not doing that task is not his friend's but his own.
One day Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) spoke of the good deeds of a righteous woman, and noting that the harm of the deniers touches even the dead of those who feel sympathy for them, said:
When this righteous woman returned from visiting the cemetery in the village of Ervas, she said to the Ghawth (k.s):
I saw the state of Molla Rasul (the Ghawth's brother) as good, but I did not see my mother's state as good. The Ghawth (k.s) said: “Whose guest were you in the village?” The woman said, so-and-so's. The Ghawth (k.s) said: “
What you saw in the cemetery was because of the house where you were a guest. It appeared so to you for that reason.
If you go to that village again, be a guest at the house of Molla Abdulghafur. Then you will see the state of Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) as good in what you see. The first house you stayed in was a denier's. The next house was among the sincere.”
Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) says: Sufism means that a person forgets the good he has done and the wrongs he has suffered from others.
The Sufi is very truthful, steadfast. Unless a hurricane arises that would move mountains from their place, the Sufi does not move from his place. That is, you cannot bring him down from his state and station.
The Sufi must not forget the wrongs he has done to others. Nor must he forget the good he has received from other people, nor keep it out of sight.
Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) cited the Maktubat of Imam Rabbani (k.s) and spoke as follows: “Everyone must give thanks in order to attain salvation.”
And thanksgiving is this:
A) To make one's belief firm according to Ahl al-Sunna wa'l-Jama'a.
B) To act according to one of the mujtahids of the four schools (may God be pleased with the efforts of them all).
C) To be honored by entering the way of the Sufis. Dressing and eating in conformity with the Sharia counts as thanksgiving.
In permissible matters such as clothing and food, intending to conform to the Sharia, even if with self-constraint, is enough to ward off the harm in them.
For example, a person who wants to wear fine clothes wears them with the aim of protecting himself against heat and cold; again, a person who feels like eating good food eats it with the intention of gaining strength for worship; and a person who frequently desires his wife has relations with her with the intention of being protected from the forbidden…
Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) says:
“One day I met the khalifa of Shaykh Uthman Tawili. While we were conversing with this blessed man, I saw that he held his breath at times and let it go at other times. I saw another khalifa do the same. The reason is this:
Holding the breath prevents all the veins from working. This state brings about the death of the self.
One day a distress fell upon my inner being. After the prayer I held my breath several times and then released it, and my distress passed.
Molla Said Gevashi suffered harm because of some objections he had made against Seyda-i Tagi (k.s).
This led Molla Said to abandon the suhba, the tawajjuh, and meeting with the master and murids. When the matter was presented to Seyda, he said:
-This state is because I have taken an aversion to him.
If a murid feels a coldness within toward his shaykh, he should understand that he is suffering harm because his shaykh feels aversion toward him.
By my life, the same thing happened to me a few times too. At one time a distress that fell upon me nearly turned me away from my murshid.
When I presented my condition to the master, he explained my state thus: At that time you had abandoned the rules of sayr wa suluk and were exerting yourself solely to abandon the sense of existence.
To attain this state you were listening to music and dancing, in season and out of season. This state ran counter to divine good pleasure. When doing such acts one must carefully watch one's time and station.
Moreover, keeping the rules of the tariqa should be preferred to the effort of abandoning the sense of existence.
Because abandoning the sense of existence benefits only the self. Keeping the pillars of the tariqa is beneficial in general.
One day Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) gave the following talk in a gathering attended by the well-known scholars and notables of our region.
I advise you to remain bound to the commands and rulings of Islam.
Follow the Sharia in all your deeds! Follow the Sharia! Seyda repeated this command “follow the Sharia” so many times that it cannot be described.
Those who do not follow the command of Islam can be neither shaykhs nor khalifas, nor are they perfect believers.
You, follow the principles of Islam! Convey them to the people too! Do what Islam commands, do not do what it forbids! Give talks often and make these matters known.
Do not stray from the path after me. The Sharia, the tariqa and the haqiqa are all the same thing. Whoever sees a difference between the Sharia and the tariqa is a heretic (zindiq).
No difference is to be seen between the Sharia, the tariqa and the haqiqa. Imam Rabbani (k.s) explains these matters better:
There may be such a difference between the Sharia, the tariqa and the haqiqa: the Sharia is to follow the commands outwardly; the tariqa is to follow the commands inwardly and with effort.
The haqiqa is to follow these rulings inwardly and naturally. To abandon an evil with the tongue is the Sharia; to abandon it with the heart under constraint is the tariqa; to abandon it willingly, without constraint, is the haqiqa. If not, there is no difference among the three. Before beginning a talk, Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) recited this couplet of Hafiz of Shiraz:
If the Beloved has not sat with us, there is no cause for objection.
Whatever the Sultan wishes comes to pass, and he is ashamed of the poor.
Then they said:
This couplet teaches us a truth. That is, it points to the Rabita and indicates up to what circumstances and what states will occur.
It says that rabita does not come about unless a complete relationship is established between the murid and his murshid. Because a sultan cannot sit beside a poor man.
One day Seyda-i Tagi (k.s) asked me this question: Ibrahim, when I am busy with supererogatory worship my rabita becomes stronger, but incomplete.
Yet when I am not busy with supererogatory worship the situation is not so. According to you, what is the reason, the wisdom of this?
I (Ibrahim Chokreshi) said: My Master knows better.
Upon this Seyda-i Tagi (k.s) said: It is that while busy with supererogatory worship a better relationship (rabita) is established with the Ghawth. Although at the end of his life the Ghawth (k.s) was not in a condition to perform supererogatory worship, in the times when his health was sound he would perform a great deal of supererogatory worship. In another talk, Seyda-i Tagi (k.s) recited this couplet:
Love without worship is like a soul without a body. See, the one whose worship is greater has the greater love as well.
When I am in a state of fear, my rabita is weaker than in a state of loving affection. The reason relates to the temperament (mashrab) of the Ghawth.
Because the temperament of the Ghawth (k.s) was founded on love and affection; there is no fear.
Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) said the following in his talk open to all:
-Provided that he is not a denier, a person who attends the talks of the followers of this exalted tariqa, even if he is not one of the people of suhba, benefits from the suhba.
The benefit gained in the suhba is deliverance from being among the people of Hell, through the himma of the great ones.
At this point in his words, relying on Imam Rabbani (k.s), he related this hadith.
“A person is with the one he loves.” (Kashf al-Khafa 2/261)
On another occasion, while with the Ghawth (k.s), despair had arisen that there was no benefit to be gained from this door.
Upon this the Ghawth (k.s) said: “Even if a person has no other gain, it is enough that he is present in this assembly of suhba,” and then recited this hadith:
“A person will be resurrected with the one he loves.” (Riyad al-Salihin/635/1445) See,
What does Khwaja Alauddin-i Attar (k.s) say in the Rashahat:
A murid should attend the suhba every day if possible, if not every two days, if that is not possible once a week, if not once a month. Or he should attend once or twice a year if possible. At the very least he should attend once in two years.
Seyda-i Tagi (k.s) related the following incident in another talk:
One day a person came to the Ghawth (k.s) and said:
My Master, so-and-so wishes to be honored by attachment to your path, but he has a worldly obstacle; what do you command? The Ghawth (k.s) said: “The one who loves is loved and counted in the tariqa.”
Seyda continued his words: On the Day of Judgment a person will be brought. It will be seen that his book of deeds is empty. There is no good deed that would be a cause of his salvation.
The man is asked, do you have no good deed at all? The man says, one day I was sitting somewhere and saw that a shadow had fallen on my place. The owner of the shadow was a man of heart. This man is forgiven for the sake of that shadow.
Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) says:
I was going to travel to a town. I delayed my journey. Thinking of your diligence, I was going to command you to come to my house every day for an hour and do service. Then I considered what good and what harm such a thing would bring.
Then the following came to my mind: a shaykh who tells Sufis to serve him must not make those services his own. He must not take pleasure, thinking that the place served is his own place.
Perhaps such a thought is a snare of the self, and means that the murshid is submitting to his self. If that is so, the service in question is harmful both for that murshid and for the murid who serves.
In a talk on formal rabita (rabita-i shakli), Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) said: A murid must attend his murshid's suhba with complete sincerity.
The murid must regard his murshid as one who has reached the rank of fana, regard all the other Sufis who attend the suhba as accepted and himself as lowly, and at the moment of the suhba ask for fayd and himma.
After the assembly of the suhba has dispersed, the murid should think, even at home, of the murshid's moment in the suhba or of the place of the suhba.
For thinking of even one of the places where the perfect murshid has been benefits the rabita. That is, it helps in drawing the image of the murshid upon the heart.
In my (Seyda-i Tagi's) early days, not knowing what was useful for establishing my rabita fully, I had pictured in my imagination a place where the Ghawth was staying.
Later I asked a Sufi who was in the service of the Ghawth what place it was that I had imagined.
The Sufi said: that is the place where the Ghawth renewed his ablution. After this I (Seyda-i Tagi) understood that, as long as the Sufi's heart is not heedless about the place where rabita is established, any place where rabita is established is useful for the concentration of the heart.
Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) said: Truthfulness and loyalty bring the murid near to the murshid. Lying and similar states take the murid far from the murshid.
When you see someone truthful, loyal, of one word, brave and valiant, of open brow, help him to enter the tariqa. Those who are not truthful come to harm.
So-and-so, though he has sincerity and love and covers most of the expenses of our house, cannot make truthfulness a habit because lying is part of his character. The harm he suffers comes from this.
Let me give you an example. The Ghawth had two Sufis.
One of them spent half of his property to meet the needs of the Ghawth. Though he had a mount, out of courtesy he came to visit on foot.
This man was a doer of righteous deeds. He spent most of his life on the tariqa. But because of certain dishonest traits he was not present at the Ghawth's side when he died.
The other murid was a person who dealt with affairs of state and was deeply involved with the world. Tagi was a truthful and honorable man. For these deeds he was in the Ghawth's close circle.
Once, because of disputes between a congregation attached to me (Seyda-i Tagi) and a congregation attached to that murid, we were thrown into prison together. This person had seen the Ghawth in his dream.
In his dream the Ghawth told him he was in the wrong and that he would get me out of prison but leave him there, and in the middle of the night that murid woke me and told me his dream. He said to me:
“Tomorrow the Ghawth (k.s) will be the cause of your release. As for us, they will not release us. The fault is our fault.” That murid learned of this event before all of us.
In a talk on rabita, Hazrat Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) said:
I do not approve of a murid seeing things contrary to etiquette in rabita. I doubt that murid's sincerity. Because seeing things contrary to etiquette in rabita is Satan.
Before attaining the station of renunciation, my self deceived me and I too had seen things contrary to etiquette in my rabita.
One day a murid says to his shaykh: My Master, during rabita I see on your head two ears like a donkey's ears.
The shaykh's answer is: Son, cut off those ears you see. When the murid, following this command, cut off the ears he saw in rabita, he witnessed that his own ears had been cut off. For that murid had seen himself in that form.
Again, one day when another murid said that he saw things contrary to etiquette in rabita, they said to him in reply:
Your sincerity is corrupt. Therefore ask pardon and forgiveness from the Almighty, and when you come to the congregation sit near the place for shoes.
Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) said:
If a Sufi, in order to correct his friend's sincerity toward the murshid, relates some of his own convictions about the murshid not as transmitted from the murshid but as though they were his own view and conviction, he suffers harm from this attitude.
If you speak thus, speak having annihilated yourself in your murshid, so that you suffer no harm.
If someone, when etiquette is not present, forces himself to adopt an attitude of etiquette so that others may see and his master may be pleased, this causes him harm.
While setting out on a journey, Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) explained the reason for a murshid's rejecting his murid:
The master Abdurrahman-i Talabani had expelled his khalifa, Darwish Amin Sirwani, from the tariqa.
Because this khalifa regarded himself as though he had no need of his murshid. In my opinion the reason for this is the wrath of the Naqshbandi masters.
Because the khalifa we are speaking of belonged to the Khalidi branch of the Naqshbandi tariqa. Later he left the Naqshbandi tariqa and entered the Rifa'i tariqa.
A similar event is the expulsion of Shaykh Abdulwahhab Susi, a khalifa of Mawlana Khalid.
He too had adopted an attitude of not needing his murshid. In my view, there is no calamity as heavy as that the murid who has incurred the murshid's wrath does not understand and notice his state.
For a murid, not seeing his fault and deficiency is the greatest affliction for him. For the murid must understand his error and fault so that, because of it, he takes refuge in his murshid and surrenders.
After listening to these words of Seyda (k.s), I (Ibrahim Chokreshi) said: May God (Exalted is He) protect us all from the wrath of the great ones.
I am very afraid because of these two spiritual illnesses of mine. One of these illnesses is excessive anger, the other is my indifference.
In response to these words of mine (Ibrahim Chokreshi), Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) said:
These illnesses of yours are nothing. Your real most dangerous illness is that you set about answering when your faults are mentioned.
This state of yours is very dangerous. The wrath of the great ones is not within their will. Let me say more: when the great ones are about to be wrathful toward someone, they take into account neither that person's service, nor his austerity, nor the hardship he has endured for their sake.
Indeed the end of this matter goes so far, may God (Exalted is He) protect us, as to the taking of his faith, whoever the murid may be.
The real cause that leads to the murid's rejection is that he does not see his own fault, and does not know the favor of his murshid upon him, and does not love the murshid's other murids, and holds any love, whatever it may be, equal to the love of his murshid; if this beloved, be it a child or anything else, becomes equal to and a rival of the love of the murshid, it makes no difference.
The reason that requires a murshid to be gracious to a murid is the murid's behaving with affection and compassion toward the other murids.
There is no more important reason than this. Moreover, a murid must seek the attribution (nisba), fayd and blessing of his fellow Sufi brothers.
This is a good character. Seyda-i Tagi (k.s) insisted on these words. He was almost about to say that behaving thus is obligatory for the murid.
When speaking of Sayyid Taha (k.s), Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s) would say:
He was very merciful; among his khalifas who had not reached perfection, though they deserved to be punished by the cutting of the nisba, he did not cut his himma from the deficient khalifas. Instead, taking from them the power of khilafa, he left them as they were.
He would explain this attitude thus: The aim of appointing khalifas who have not reached perfection to service is that the people may benefit and profit from them.
Because the benefit the people gain from them is greater than from the khalifas who possess perfection.
As long as they are beneficial to the people, leave them in their places; if not, cut the nisba from them. May the Almighty protect us all from incurring the wrath of the great ones.
After the afternoon prayer in Nurshin, because a person left the row and because of some of their attitudes and behaviors, Seyda-i Tagi (k.s) scolded us in anger and said:
Your actions are not for me but for your own selves. You will see no benefit from these actions of yours.
In prayer, take care of the tranquility of the pillars (ta'dil al-arkan), pray in the first row, and do not leave the row until the tasbih prayer is finished. These are good things. The opposite is not acceptable.
After the dawn prayer, let the imam not leave his place and join the congregation until the sun rises. Let him not leave his place even if he has to crawl on his knees. Thus he follows the Sunna.
Let no one leave his place after the dawn prayer and join the congregation until the sun rises. Let him not leave his place even if he has to crawl on his knees.
This act, as it is in accord with the Sunna, brings the one who does it a reward equal to the reward of Hajj and Umra.
I asked Seyda-i Tagi (k.s) whether changing one's manner of sitting, without changing place, is contrary to the Sunna, and he replied: - In my opinion doing so is not contrary to the Sunna.
One day we complained to Abdurrahman Tagi (k.s), saying that we could not obtain benefit.
The Blessed One said:
Perfection is that its possessor realizes that he is not perfect, sees the faults and shortcomings of his self, and perceives the attributes of perfection of God (Exalted is He)… In short, one must shed the sense of existence and selfhood.
According to what I heard from Khalidi Oleki (k.s);

