Making Up an Unslaughtered Sacrifice
If a person slaughters a sacrifice intending it as the making up of a sacrifice he did not slaughter, it is not a make-up but a voluntary offering. For making up the sacrifice he did not slaughter, a sheep of medium value, or its value, is given as charity.
(Fatawa al-Hindiyya vol. 5 p. 305).
If a person buys a sheep with the intention of sacrifice and the days of the feast pass without his having slaughtered it, whether rich or poor: if he made it obligatory upon himself by saying “I must sacrifice this sheep,” or, even without saying so, if he is poor and bought a sheep with the intention of sacrificing, he gives that sheep alive as charity. If he is rich and has not made the slaughter of a specific sheep obligatory upon himself, then whether or not he had bought a sheep for sacrifice, he may, if he wishes, buy a sheep of medium value and give it alive as charity. If he wishes, he gives its value as charity. (Fatawa al-Hindiyya vol. 5 p. 296)
An important point
If an animal bought for sacrifice is lost or stolen, and a replacement sacrificial animal is bought, and then the lost animal is found, then if the owner is poor he must slaughter both. If he is rich, he slaughters only one.
Because, by buying an animal with the intention of sacrifice while poor and not under obligation, that very animal has been designated to be sacrificed and has become obligatory upon the poor person as a kind of vow. (M. Islam ilmihali p. 392)
A rich person, on the other hand, is already obliged to slaughter a sacrifice. Buying an animal does not necessarily make it a condition that he sacrifice that animal. Because he has made no special intention over that animal; he has bought a sacrificial animal only because he has a religious debt. Since he may sacrifice either it or any animal, he slaughters the first animal that was found after being lost or the animal he newly bought. That is, it is sufficient for him to slaughter one of the two.
(B. Islam ilmihali p. 392)