Can Damlaları

Can the Sacrifice Money Be Given as Charity to the Poor?

Can the Sacrifice Money Be Given as Charity to the Poor?

“Instead of buying and slaughtering a sacrifice, can this money be given to the needy and the poor?”
Let us take the answer to this question from the great scholar Molla Hüsrev (may God have mercy on him), one of the military judges and Sheikh al-Islams of the era of Mehmed the Conqueror. In his esteemed work Durar al-Hukkam, a commentary on Ghurar al-Ahkam, that great figure says:
“Slaughtering one's sacrifice on the days of sacrifice is more virtuous than giving the money for the sacrifice as charity. For slaughtering the sacrifice is obligatory (wajib) or a sunna. Giving charity, however, is merely voluntary (tatawwu'), that is, supererogatory.” (Kitab al-Udhiyya, vol. 1)

As we have stated before, the sacrifice is not in the nature of a supererogatory act of worship according to any of the schools of Ahl al-Sunna. According to the Hanafi school to which we belong, it is obligatory. The proof that it is obligatory is the noble saying of the Messenger of God (peace be upon him), our Master: “Whoever is well-off and does not offer a sacrifice, let him not approach our place of prayer.” This noble hadith was narrated by Imam Ahmad ibn Hanbal and Ibn Majah, may God have mercy on them both. Only one who abandons an obligation deserves such a warning, that is, a threat.
(Molla Hüsrev, ibid.)

In case it could not be performed in its time and is left to be made up, which act of worship is made up and how has been explained down to the smallest detail. This is the case for the sacrifice too: “If a person who has let the days of slaughter pass is poor, he gives the sacrificial animal itself, alive, as charity; because in our school, for a poor person, performing the sacrifice that he bought with the intention of sacrificing is obligatory. If he is rich, he may give as charity the price, that is the value, of the sacrifice, whether it is in his possession or one he bought. Thus he discharges this obligation.” (Molla Hüsrev, ibid.)